Showing posts with label Bronte. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bronte. Show all posts

Monday, June 6, 2022

Commemorating WWII in Haworth

 


While going through my photos, these memories of our 2012 visit to Haworth made me smile. The town had recently held a WWII celebration. This shop--our last stop--showed plenty of plucky British spirit.

I particularly like this important reminder of the need to conserve during those difficult times.



Women played an important role in all aspects of British life. While men not eligible to serve in the military joined the Home Guard, Haworth women joined the Home Guard Women Auxilieries.


 

Good news buoyed the spirits in those difficult times.



Good food--when the locals could get it--also helped. I don't remember eating an ice cream cone there, but apparently I did. Well, I had just taken a long walk through the nearby countryside.

I wonder what flavor I enjoyed. Rum Raisin, perhaps?


The Bronte connection led me to Haworth. I left with a unique kind of toffees I found nowhere else (on subsequent trips to England), a beautiful picture painted by a local, and some great memories.

Dragon Dave

P.S. Read about Haworth's Home Guard in the link below:

Haworth Home Guard

Wednesday, April 6, 2016

Charlotte Bronte & the Jew Basket

The sign outside the Bronte museum
in Haworth, England

In Charlotte Bronte's novel Shirley, Caroline Helstone receives some female visitors. When it comes time for tea,

Caroline had to usher them upstairs, to help them to unshawl, smooth their hair, and make themselves smart; to reconduct them to the drawing-room, to distribute amongst them books of engravings, or odd things purchased from the Jew-basket. She was obliged to be a purchaser, though she was a slack contributor.

Charlotte Bronte describes this Jew-basket as:

A monster collection of pincushions, needlebooks, cardracks, workbags, articles of infant wear, etc., etc., etc., made by the willing or reluctant hands of the Christian ladies of a parish, and sold perforce to the heathenish gentlemen thereof, at prices unblushingly exorbitant. 

So, the women of the village make craft items, and contribute these to the Jew-basket. The basket then gets handed off to women in the village. Some eagerly await its coming. Others dread its arrival. But when it comes your time to take charge of the Jew-basket, you have only one option: sell, sell, sell!

So, what was the money used for?

The proceeds of such compulsory sales are applied to the conversion of the Jews, the seeking out of the ten missing tribes, or to the regeneration of the interesting coloured population of the globe. 

It's hard to really know how to interpret that last sentence. It would be easy, in today's politically correct society, to cast that sentence in a negative context. But, as a nonJewish, nonEnglish Christian male, the aims of the Jew-basket society seem fairly positive. 

The good women of England wish to help fund a ministry to preach the Gospel to the Jews.

I particularly like the second portion of their stated purpose: "the seeking out of the ten missing tribes." The biblical books of Kings 1 & 2 tell of the split of ancient Israel into northern and southern kingdoms. Unlike the southern kingdom, the northern kingdom was not only conquered, but its inhabitants dispersed. Many were no doubt forced to intermarry with nonJews. Over time, their heritage was lost. So an effort to seek out the descendants of these missing tribes seems a noble goal.

I don't know if there ever was such a Jewish Ministry society in England. Perhaps Charlotte Bronte was merely satirizing a common fundraising practice. But I'd be interested to learn if a group of nineteenth century English Christians actually raised funds for such a purpose, and if they were successful in helping the descendants of the northern kingdom reclaim their Jewish heritage. Wouldn't you?

Dragon Dave 

Monday, April 4, 2016

Charlotte Bronte & The Jews

A short wander outside Haworth

‘You have no binding engagement at home perhaps, Caroline?’ (Robert Moore asks).
‘I never have: some children’s socks, which Mrs Ramsden has ordered, to knit for the Jews’ basket; but they will keep.’
‘Jew’s basket be — sold! Never was utensil better named. Anything more Jewish than it — its contents, and their prices — cannot be conceived."

Curiosity over what Charlotte Bronte was referring to in her novel Shirley led me to a post of The Jewish Quarterly, written by professional author Tamar Yellin. In her article, Ms. Yellin explains that she became aware of the Bronte sisters' fiction at the tender age of ten. During her teens she read very little that was not written by members of this famous, literary family. And yet, she is Jewish, and every time Charlotte, or another family member references the Jews, they do so in a negative context.

So great was her love for the Bronte family's stories that she grew up dreaming of being a Bronte. She wrote fiction inspired by the Brontes. When she reached adulthood, she moved to a small village near Haworth, in an area of England she affectionately labels Bronteland. There she could live out her lifelong dream of wandering through the hills and valleys, and woods and moors, where Emily, Anne, and Charlotte Bronte once strolled.

And yet, every time Charlotte, or one of the sisters wrote something negative about the Jews, it hurt her.

The best stories aren't merely inoffensive pleasure-reading. They're meant to hurt, and bring us pain. Why? Because when we are in pain, that helps us glimpse the truth. Pain helps us see the world, and our place in it, all that more clearly. Pain helps define us, challenges us, and hopefully, makes us better people. 

Many people would have noticed these anti-Jewish remarks, labeled the book offensive, and never picked up another Bronte book. Some might have organized Bronte book-burnings. Others might have become critics, and written scathing reviews of the Bronte sisters' stories and poetry. Tamar Yellin chose to find something meaningful and positive in the Brontes' writings. She chose to look past the little she did not like, and embrace the riches beneath the occasional slur. She channeled the Brontes' work to mold herself into a stronger, better, more fulfilled person.

That's tolerance. That's love. That's...

Inspiring.

Dragon Dave

Related Internet Links
Tamar Yellin in The Jewish Quarterly

Wednesday, March 30, 2016

Charlotte Bronte Vs Jane Austen



I've read three Jane Austen novels, and enjoyed them all. But something keeps drawing me back to the Bronte sisters' novels. While I should have long since started reading Emma, Jane Austen's fourth novel, instead I'm reading Shirley, my Bronte sisters' fifth book. Austen fills her novels with plenty of social commentary, some of which she drops in as satire. They are by far easier reading than the Bronte sisters' fiction. And yet...

Like Jane Austen's novels, Shirley informs me about the time in which it was written. In this case, she's introducing me to life in Yorkshire, England during the Napoleonic Wars. While Textile Mill owners felt the need to industrialize to keep down expenses, this put tremendous numbers of people out of work. As Mill owners were not allowed to sell their textiles to America, as a result of treaty issues during the war, this severely limited their income. The need to industrialize put tremendous numbers of the poor out of work. This leads to the Luddite rebellion against industrialization. Through Robert Moore, the mill owner, we even learn of Wellington's tactics, victories, and failures during the Napoleonic Wars. Then, of course, there are attitudes toward women, and the role they were expected to play, in the early nineteenth century English society.

Perhaps it's the pain that undergirds the Bronte sisters' novels that imbue them with added richness and depth. There's no doubting that Jane Austen's characters undergo plenty of pain in her stories. But pain seems to seeps from the very pores of the Bronte sisters' novels. It bleeds from every scene, every page. Consider, for a minute, Caroline Helstone. Her father died, and her mother abandoned her. She lives with her uncle, who thinks that all women are simple, if not useless, creatures. He refuses to deal with her as a real person. His wife, by all accounts a beautiful young woman with spirit, ostensibly died ignored and unloved within a few years of their marriage. Shirley herself is an orphan, forced to operate in a man's world, with only her former governess for company. It's the pain, and the loss she senses, that draws Shirley to Caroline.

But then, unlike Jane Austen, the Bronte sisters lived in poverty. Due to poor living conditions, her brother Branwell and her sister Emily died while Charlotte was writing Shirley. Her remaining sister Anne died the year of Shirley's publication. I suppose it's that hard struggle for life, and the unavoidable reality of death, undergirds Shirley, and all the Bronte sisters' novels, with such vivid pain and loss. 

Still, while I apparently find the Bronte sisters' novels more compelling, I'm glad Jane Austen didn't have to experience that.

Dragon Dave

Monday, March 28, 2016

Charlotte Bronte on Heartless Priests & Career Women

The Bronte family church,
St. Michael And All Angels,
in Haworth, England

After a long break, I'm diving into the Bronte sisters' novels again. This time, it's Shirley, by Charlotte Bronte. She paints a vivid portrait of Yorkshire, England in the early nineteenth century. Two aspects of life she especially concentrates on are the role of priests and women. 

In Shirley, Charlotte Bronte introduces us to a trio of Curets, who are ruled with an iron hand by Reverend Helstone. The Curets seem disinterested in practical matters, and spend much of their time drinking and arguing. Reverend Helstone led his wife to an early grave, and regards his niece Caroline as property. He sends her off each day to be educated by the sister of Robert Moore, the local mill owner, but refuses to have a real conversation with her. 

After he has a dispute with Robert Moore, Reverend Helstone cuts short her lessons and forbids her to meet or speak with either again. Not only does this leave Caroline with nothing to do each day, but Robert's sister was a friend, and she had fallen in love with Robert. She grows depressed in her alienation, begins to see her future as an old maid, and wastes away. When she tries to take command of her life, and give herself something to live for, he refuses to allow her to work as a governess. He decides instead that all her ills will be cured if he buys her a pretty dress.

This portrait of a hard, cold, woman-hater as a priest is an interesting factor in Shirley. I don't know much about Charlotte's upbringing, but her father was a priest in the Church of England, and she grew up in the parsonage. I can't help but wonder if her depiction of Reverend Helstone, and his assistant priests, is in some ways a reflection of him. Even the name she gave him, a combination of Hell and Stone, seems suggestive, not just of the roles and characters of English priests, but also the types of sermons they preached.

But again, Shirley reflects a society in which women's roles were rather limited. When she meets the title character, Caroline shares her desire to have a career. But in some ways, Caroline is glad she doesn't, as working women tend to get hard and masculine as a result of their careers.

I wonder what Charlotte Bronte would think of priests, and the increased number of professional, career women, in contemporary society.

Dragon Dave

Thursday, July 30, 2015

In Emily Bronte's Footsteps

Near Haworth, England

"I'll walk where my own nature would be leading.
It vexes me to choose another guide."


A salute to the author of Wuthering Heights on her birthday.

Dragon Dave

Monday, June 15, 2015

The Link Between Michael Moorcock & Ashley Jackson

Science Fiction and Fantasy author Michael Moorcock may not view himself as a world-builder, at least not in the same category as the Bronte sisters, but their fiction clearly influenced him. After all, when most of us hear the term world-building, we tend to think in Hard Science Fiction terms, like knowing the gravity of a planet, its orbit around its sun, its age and the atmospheric makeup, those sorts of things. The type of writing that authors like Peter F Hamilton, Gregory Benford, and Dan Simmons do so well. Or we think of it in terms of Fantasy novelists, who construct elaborate histories for their invented lands, families whose heritage goes back thousands of years, and structure them with class systems and people filling the necessary tasks to enable such a world to function. This brings authors like J. R. R. Tolkien and Steven Brust to mind. But clearly, the stories of the Bronte sisters evoked characters, a society, an era, and landscapes that were so important to Michael Moorcock that, when asked a question about world-building, the first writers that leapt to his mind were Emily, Anne, and Charlotte Bronte.

Another person touched deeply by the sisters' work is artist Ashley Jackson. While enjoying the comfort of a warm bus during our "Last of the Summer Wine" tour in Holmfirth, England, the guide pointed out the artist's studio, and suggested that it was worth visiting. Later that day, we did just that, and saw canvases covering the walls, and set upon easels, all evoking the grey, stormy weather we had enjoyed that day.



Enjoying a rainy day outside Holmfirth inside a warm bus
on our "Last of the Summer Wine" tour.

During our visit, a sales associate handed us a brochure, in which Ashley Jackson described some of his favorite views in and around Holmfirth. So the next day we set out on the route Ashley had outlined for us, and drank in the lush, green surroundings.



Taking the Ashley Jackson walk outside Holmfirth.

If you're a fan of the British sitcom (or Britcom) "Last of the Summer Wine," or for any other reason ever decide to visit Holmfirth, you can download this map at Ashley Jackson's website.

Ashley Jackson has often said that what the Bronte sisters did with their pens, he attempts to do with his brushes. Throughout his life, he has aided several Bronte causes, such as saving landmarks that inspired their stories. Also notable is that he usually only paints during the winter when the sky is cloudy, and a storm is imminent. He even paints during the rain! Imagine painting watercolors onto a canvas, while standing in a wet field, the wind blowing the rain horizontally into your face. This is Ashley Jackson's world. While he depicts the world of today, his paintings transport you back in time, so you can see the world through the Bronte sisters' eyes. 

Pausing for a steak pie and a Diet-Coke in Haworth,
before seeing more of the Bronte sister's hometown.

Even if I never associated world-building with the Bronte sisters, or for that matter with Michael Moorcock, there's no doubt that the best authors fill readers with visions of their fictional landscapes, and imbue them with a reality that makes us desire to visit them. (Or inspire us to write similar stories, or evoke such landscapes and realities in some other artistic form, such as Ashley Jackson does). How else can one explain the tremendous popularity of such small, out-of-the-way towns like Holmfirth and Haworth, isolated locales in which TV writer Roy Clarke and literary icons Emily, Anne, and Charlotte Bronte set their stories? 

Taking in the views a short walk from Haworth.

Now, if only one could visit Elric's home of Melnibone, and enjoy a tour inside a comfortable, warm bus. Provided I was assured that Elric's sword Stormbringer wouldn't drink my soul, I'd sign up for that. Well, maybe...

Dragon Dave

Wednesday, June 10, 2015

Michael Moorcock on the Bronte Sisters


In the December 2014 issue of Locus magazine, longtime Science Fiction and Fantasy author Michael Moorcock combatted the notion that he was a world-builder. "I think the notion of world-building is a failure of literary sophistication," he responded. "Take the Romantic writers of the 19th century, particularly the Brontes. The Brontes loved the idea of of depicting weather to suit moods--it's called the pathetic fallacy, where you give inanimate things animate qualities. The point of that style of writing is that it used landscape and weather, all exteriors, to symbolize internal conflict within the individual or within a small group of individuals."

Having been born and raised in England, it's understandable that Michael Moorcock should have a greater knowledge of the history of English literature, and know many of the themes and philosophies of that country's great writers. Having read Wuthering Heights, Jane Eyre, Agnes Grey and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall recently, I confess that such a notion completely passed over me when I read these novels. I simply bonded with the characters, and followed them through their adventures. A simple Google search demonstrates that many feel similar to Moorcock, and upon reflection, it's easy to see that most of the titles denote weather and landscape. Wuthering refers to a strong, roaring wind, and Wildfell suggests a wild fell, or a rugged hill. Grey could certainly refer to the weather, as the sky in England on my vacations there has often been that color. And Eyre, while it offers no direct connection to the weather, refers to the circuit made by an itinerant judge, which is an apt description of the protagonist's rigorous life journey in that novel. 

Actually, now that I think of it, Agnes Grey is an interesting title. Agnes, her given name, denotes holiness or purity, and she certainly was that. But Grey, her family name, indicates the situation into which she was born, one which offered her a murky future, a life that offered few options, and no clear (or sure) means of advancement. Wow, I guess I'm going to have to give a little more thought to the names of my characters, as well as the titles of my novels.

Weather certainly plays a strong part in Wuthering Heights, with Lockwood falling ill during a storm at the beginning of the novel. This forces him into bed for the majority of the narrative, during which his servant tells him the story of his neighbor's lives. And in Jane Eyre, young Jane faces the cruelty of weather during her upbringing at an orphanage. What at first seems like a pleasant, even idyllic locale proves anything but that in the winter, when the cold and the damp make all the residents terribly sick, and takes the life of her best friend, a young girl who Jane feels is the best human being who ever lived.

I understand where Michael Moorcock is coming from in his rejection of the term world-building. As he points out, he has no interest in knowing the social security system or gross national product of his character Elric's kingdom of Melnibone. But in creating Elric, he defined not only his protagonist's inner qualities, but demonstrated how Elric interacted with his surroundings. In that way, he created a world every bit as real as that of the Brontes, one Elric inhabited and cared about, one drawn as colorfully as that of his protagonist. And so, in that way, Michael Moorcock is a world-builder, whether or not he likes to define himself as one.

Someday, when I'm a published author, if he's still alive and we happen to meet, I'd love to talk with Michael Moorcock about some of the novels he's written. While complimenting an author often helps break the ice, I guess in this case I shouldn't attempt to kickstart the discussion by complimenting him for his abilities as a world-builder. Another usually-safe topic--discussing the weather--could also prove a fallacy in his case. But the idea of being granted an audience with one of one's writing hero's, and using it to discuss the weather, seems a rather pathetic move in any case. 

Dragon Dave

Thursday, May 8, 2014

Anne Bronte on Spousal Loyalty

A View of Haworth, Anne Bronte's hometown

In the opening chapters of Anne Bronte’s novel The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, Gilbert Markham meets the reclusive Mrs. Helen Graham. Although she does nothing to encourage him, his regard for her grows as the months pass. When he confronts Helen with the rumor swirling around her, and insists on knowing her past, she rips a section from her diary and presses it into his hands. He flies home, locks himself in his room, and spends the entire night reading.

From those pages, he learns how she met and fell in love with Arthur Huntington. When he proposed marriage to her, she refuted all her aunt’s allegations regarding his character. Frustrated, her aunt insists that Mr. Huntington's bad reputation is thoroughly deserved, and asks how she’ll feel throughout eternity if he is consigned to the fires of Hell. Helen insists that Mr. Huntington is not so evil or incorrigible as to remain in Hell forever. Rather, she’s found enough scripture to believe that, after a period of suffering in Purgatory, he will be reunited with her in Heaven.

Following their honeymoon in Europe, they spend several months together on his Grassdale estate. Then the newlyweds visit London. Helen objects to his visits to his club, and how he conducts himself amongst his friends. So Arthur sends her back to Grassdale, insisting he will follow shortly. Instead, months pass until he returns home.

While she wants to believe the best in him, and that he still loves her as fervently as ever, she finds the physical separation from him difficult to endure. As the years pass, she gives birth to a son, whom she also names Arthur, and his presence helps her endure the months apart when her husband lives in London, and spends their money extravagantly. It doesn’t help when Walter Hargrave, who runs a neighboring estate, stops by to tell her of Arthur’s objectionable behavior. She does not feel it right that he should visit her in Arthur’s absence, and refuses to hear anything he wishes to say about her husband’s conduct. When Arthur returns to Grassdale, bringing all his friends with him to continue their carefree London lifestyle, Helen orders her maid Rachel to not share with her any observations that might give her a negative opinion regarding her husband.

Eventually, Helen witnesses actions she cannot condone, and realizes that Arthur is totally and hopelessly corrupt. Yet she believes it her duty to remain at Grassdale, and manage the estate. Only after he demonstrates a commitment to corrupting their son does she flee, seeking the isolation of Wildfell Hall and the anonymity of an assumed name. 

As rays of sunlight illumine his dark room, Gilbert sets down the torn-out pages. He now knows the story surrounding her and Mr. Lawrence was untrue. He hurries back to Wildfell Hall and declares his love for her. Helen admits that, despite her best efforts, she has come to love him too. But she refuses to listen to his arguments and rationalizations, and insists they must never see each other again.

A few weeks later, Gilbert learns that she has abandoned Wildfell Hall.

All through her marriage, Helen remains loyal to her husband, and seeks to safeguard his reputation, if nowhere else than in her mind. She repeatedly ignores the urging of others, whether they be Walter Hargrave, Rachel, or Gilbert Markham, when they argue that, as Arthur has wronged her, she should declare herself free of him. Instead, she remains wed to him in her heart, and conducts herself accordingly. For his part, Gilbert is shocked to learn where she travels after she leaves Wildfell Hall. To him, her actions prove that her spousal loyalty is even more extreme than he could have believed possible, and that Helen must be more angel than human. 

But then, all the best wives are.

Dragon Dave

Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Anne Bronte and the Power of Rumors

Farmland near Haworth,
Anne Bronte's hometown
In Anne Bronte's novel The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, we meet Gilbert Markham, a farmer in 19th Century England. He’s a responsible man who grows his crops, cares for his animals, and uses income from the farm to purchase additional land. As his father has died, he taken over the role of family provider. With him live his mother, who orchestrates the running of his household, his younger brother Fergus, who seems to take nothing seriously, and his sister Rose, who takes an interest in everything that occurs in their community.

Gilbert may not be a socialite like his sister, but he’s gained the esteem of society. He’s befriended Frederick Lawrence, a man who grew up in nearby Wildfell Hall, but now manages another estate. He frequently visits Rev. Millward, a man of strong beliefs and rigid principles. Not only does he enjoy the priest's company, but he’s also attracted to Eliza, the man’s youngest daughter. While Eliza returns his interest, his mother pleads with Gilbert not to pursue her. He honors her request, but hopes his mother will eventually set aside her disapproval of Eliza, and allow him to ask for her hand in marriage. 

Then a widow and her young son rent Wildfell Hall, a deteriorating manor house on a nearby estate, and everything changes in Gilbert’s world.

As Rose craves the company of others, she needs little convincing to pay her respects to Mrs. Helen Graham and her young son Arthur. Soon Rose is visiting Wildfell Hall regularly, and bringing along Fergus and their mother. After his long workday, Rose regales Gilbert with descriptions of Mrs. Graham: her looks, her actions, and her taste in clothes and furniture. On those rare occasions when, compelled by Rose or Rev. Millward, Mrs. Graham attends civic functions, Gilbert finds the young widow stern, reclusive, and argumentative. Yet he likes young Arthur enormously, and there is something about Helen Graham that intrigues him. After awhile, he accompanies family members on visits to Wildfell Hall, and forges reasons to make solitary journeys there. When he's out managing his farm, he keeps an eye out for Mrs. Graham. If he spots her walking in certain places at regular intervals, he returns to those places, and at those times, so that he can pretend to bump into her.

Gilbert’s family and friends notice his rising interest in Mrs. Graham and her son. Equally noticeable are Frederick Lawrence's visits to Wildfell Hall. A story circulates that something improper is going on between Mrs. Graham and Mr. Lawrence. As Gilbert admires Helen for her intelligence and convictions, he refuses to believe it. Over time, he perceives two young women at the center of this story: the impishly beautiful Eliza, and her talented friend Jane Wilson, a young woman who has designs on Frederick Lawrence. Previously he has held both women in high regard. Yet how can he claim that the story they are spreading is a baseless slander? Perhaps Gilbert is too biased in his opinions of Mrs. Helen Graham. Perhaps his initial assessment of her was correct, and he should accept the opinion of others he has known far longer. For nearly everyone in society whom he loves and respects, including Rev. Millward and his family, have accepted this unproven story as the truth.

Such is the power of rumors.

Dragon Dave

Thursday, May 1, 2014

Anne Bronte on Appreciating What You Have

Wychnor Hall in the English Midlands,
a 19th Century gentleman's manor house 


In Anne Bronte’s novel, The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, Helen Lawrence opts for love in marrying Arthur Huntington. And in many ways, he seems to return that love. Certainly he seeks her out at social events. He pays frequent visits to her uncle and aunt’s home. He snatches her portraits of him to his heart. And, as his association with her grows, his inclination to spend more time with her increases.

Their first few months of marriage, alone on his estate, are the happiest of Helen’s life. Arthur seems to cherish their time together. Yet in little ways, he seems thoughtless as to Helen’s feelings and concerns. During their courtship, he stole kisses and portraits she would not have readily given him. He also flirted with the beautiful and accomplished Annabella, the niece of the elderly “scoundrel” Mr. Wilmot. During their engagement, he continued to associate with friends she disapproved of. During their honeymoon in Europe, he rushed her from place to place, never allowing her to explore the exotic ports of call that she has long wished to visit. He wanted to have her to himself, and only for himself.

After their marriage, while he attends church with her, he never shows reverence for the service. Nor does he share Helen’s beliefs. He expects Helen to set him atop a pedestal set higher than God, and place lesser emphasis on any tenets of faith and religious practice that do not revolve around him. This is too far for Helen to go. While she loves him, her faith and convictions remain paramount to her. So when he tells her stories about the revelry and gambling he and his friends have enjoyed in London, and also how they convinced their obviously alcoholic friend Lord Lowborough to continue drinking, she cannot countenance such behavior. Over time, this barrier to full ownership of her soul becomes an obstacle between them, at least in his mind. Any counseling she then offers him only makes his lack of complete lordship over her more painful, and this sends him back to the easy-going camaraderie of his friends.

Arthur Huntington is not an evil man. Had he been one, Helen would never have married him. But he demonstrates insecurities that his love of drinking will later amplify. His tendency to make light of any situation made Helen fall in love with him. Later, his inability to take anything seriously will allow appalling behavior to enter their home. He is an English gentleman of the 19th Century, a rich young man who never had to work or prove himself. Lacking a purpose in life, he allows Helen to manage their books while he spends their money. He has too much time for vice, and lacks the discipline for virtue. He is, in every way, the kind of man that Helen’s aunt warned her against, a handsome man lacking in sense and principle. 

Arthur Huntington has much to appreciate: his wife Helen, his fine manor house and estate, his loyal servants, and his friends. In time, Helen will even give him a son. But because he does not cherish all that he has, and views life as little more than a game, he eventually loses everything. Sadly, that's a fate that can affect anyone at any time, and at any economic level. But then, it's always easier to point out how another person doesn't appreciate all he has, and make the most of his life, than it is to examine one's one shortcomings, isn't it?

Dragon Dave


Tuesday, April 29, 2014

Anne Bronte on Infatuation

A rich Gentleman's snuff box, circa 1775-80,
courtesy of the Victoria & Albert Museum in London

In her novel The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, Anne Bronte introduces us to Helen Lawrence, a young woman approaching marriable age. In the 19th Century, the chasm between the rich and the poor was vast, and crossing the distance required truly extraordinary abilities. In order to preserve a family's wealth and position, parents and guardians deemed it essential to marry off their descendants to people of similar social and economic standing. In order to prevent diluting the family's hold on the aristocracy, parents might disown their children, as the mother in Anne Bronte's Agnes Grey discovered when she married a poor English priest. Conventional wisdom also dictated that women must marry as soon as a suitable candidate is found, or risk becoming an old maid. With this aim in mind, Helen's guardians, her aunt and uncle, leave their comfortable country estate behind, and travel to London for "the season."

In London, her aunt and uncle usher Helen through balls, dinner parties, and other social functions. As the season progresses, her aunt and uncle present Helen with two candidates for marriage. Each is much closer to their age than that of Helen, and reflects aspects of their personalities. Her uncle favors the “elderly” Mr. Wilmot, while her aunt applauds the scrupulous morals and sensibilities of (the still much older) Mr. Boarham. But Helen’s heart goes out to another man, of the same social and economic strata as her own, and only a mere ten years older than her. His name is Mr. Huntington.

Helen's aunt cannot understand why Arthur Huntington has struck her fancy. She reminds Helen of their talk before traveling to London. Helen had assured her that she would not fall for a man “deficient in sense and principle, however handsome or charming in some respect he might be.” Her aunt asks if Arthur Huntington is a good man, and Helen answers that he is good “in some respects.” Her aunt asks if he is a man of principle, and Helen responds, “Perhaps not, but it is only for a want of thought.” Helen then goes on to assert that, as he is basically good, she can advise him as to how to make the best moral choices and behavior. His aunt is dubious, as Arthur Huntington is already ten years older than her. Yet despite certain worrying aspects of his behavior, Arthur has rescued her several times from the tiresome Mr. Boarham, caught her imagination with his flair and vitality, and made her laugh. Thus, he has found his way to her heart. When she is not with him, Helen dreams of him, and sketches or paints his portrait from memory.

As Arthur Huntington excites her, Helen forgets that principles and character are forged over time in the furnaces of determined thought and action. Faced with two unappealing prospects, she leaps for an attractive third. Infatuated, she believes that she can overcome any of his deficiencies and make the relationship work for both of them. Instead of rebuffing Mr. Wilmot and Mr. Boarham, and waiting for a more appealing prospect capable of meeting her aunt and uncle’s approval, she believes what her heart tells her. Riding a wave of emotion, she discards her resolutions and marries someone of less than sterling character, believing that her chosen partner will discard his own likes and inclinations, and allow her to reform him. It’s a risky venture, but as they say, the greater the risk, the greater her potential reward. After all, if Helen can work her magic on Arthur, she can have everything, right? Love, wealth, status…and of course, excitement.

Above all, God deliver us for boredom. (Or, in this case, Mr. Boarham).

Dragon Dave

Monday, April 28, 2014

Anne Bronte on Defying Your Elders

A View from Haworth

In her first novel, Agnes Grey, Anne Bronte introduced us to a smart young girl, yearning to demonstrate her capabilities to the world. She yearns to grow, to stretch herself, but is constrained by familial concern and lack of finances. Agnes might make an ideal wife, yet in England at that time few aspiring men would give a young woman from a poor family a second glance. Nor is she likely to meet such extraordinary men, should they exist, as she does not live in the bustling city of London, but an out-of-the-way village much like Haworth, where Anne grew up. Nor do her parents wish her to hire herself out as a governess. They see such a situation as fraught with danger, and don’t believe she’s up to the challenge. Agnes may have no control over her marital status, but with regard to her vocation, she defies her parents, and continually argues with them until they relent, and allow her to advertise for a position. Unfortunately, both of the jobs she takes fall far below her expectations and hopes.

In her second novel, The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, Anne Bronte introduces us to Helen Lawrence. Although she came from a moderately well off family, her mother died when she was young, and her father didn’t want her. So she went to live with her aunt and uncle, who reared her with the aim of marrying her into a family of wealth and social prominence. Her aunt’s reasoning and coaching in the selection of a perfect mate seem logical and wise. Yet, when she “comes out” in London society, Helen is appalled by her aunt and uncle’s choices. The first, Mr. Wilmot, is a rich friend whom her uncle views as a prime candidate for marriage. Helen doesn’t mince words when recording her observations of the man in her diary. He strikes her as annoying, disagreeable and ugly. As if that weren’t enough, in one sentence she mentions that he is elderly, and twice that he is old.  Her aunt scolds her for describing him as wicked, and later, as a reprobate, but even she admits that he’s no saint.

So, Mr. Wilmot is no Roger Moore, it appears. (Nor, for that matter, an under-appreciated Val Kilmer.)

Her aunt and uncle then introduce her to Mr. Boarham. Her aunt especially thinks the world of him, and never ceases to sing his praises. Certainly in his own mind, he sees himself as a font of information, which he wishes to share with her. Helen immediately tries to avoid him at social events, for he continually seeks out her company. Once he has found her, he steadfastly remains by her side for the rest of the evening, enlightening her with all manner of useful facts. All too soon, he arrives at her aunt and uncle’s house. In his generous marriage proposal, he expounds on how he will overlook all her faults and deficiencies. He is much older than her, and thus a vast gulf separates them in temperament and wisdom. Helen assures him repeatedly that she appreciates his kind offer, but must decline it. He refuses to accept her answer though, certain that, as in all things, she will soon realize how wonderful life with him could be, and how fortunate she is that he selected her as his mate.

Like the man she has chosen, her aunt sees Mr. Boarham as the ideal choice. Helen argues that she must marry for love, and that she would grow to hate a man who constantly drones on and on about topics on which she has no interest, and who sees himself as superior to her in all things. She has already labeled him Mr. Bore’em in her diary, so you get some sense of her regard for him.

So, when it comes to the crucial moment of a young, rich woman’s existence, her season of “coming out,” Helen finds herself at odds with her aunt and uncle’s choices for her. Despite all the years of education and social conditioning they have given her, their “best” choices for her seem, at best, unrealistic. Although they clearly want the best for her, and as much as she loves them and respects them, she refuses to trust their judgment in these matters. But then, we were all young once, certain that we were right and our elders were wrong.

Of course, I was always right. But then, I’m unique.

Dragon Dave

Wednesday, April 9, 2014

Anne Bronte: Agnes Grey & Fanny Price

The third in a three-part series on this English literary classic…

A side chapel in Haworth Parish Church,
where Anne Bronte worshipped.

As I read Agnes Grey, I couldn’t help comparing it to Jane Austen’s novels. In particular, it reminded me of young Fanny Price, the heroine of Mansfield Park. Like Fanny, Agnes quietly gets on with the job, and never seeks the limelight. She knows what is right, and never swerves from her code of ethics. She holds out hope that she will achieve what she desires, even though she knows the odds are against her. Aware of the limitations imposed on her by society, she nonetheless does what she can for others. Her circle of influence may be small, but those within it gradually realize her worth, and by the end of each novel, both women achieve their heart’s desire.

(Spoiler Alert: If you plan to read either of these novels soon, you should stop reading now!)

In Mansfield Park, the love of Fanny’s life is none other than her cousin Edmund, with whom she has grown up, and in whose household she lives. Edmund falls in love with another woman over the course of the novel, but ultimately realizes that Fanny is the woman he loves most. They marry, and he becomes the local parish priest.

In Agnes Grey, the title character meets a young curate named Edward. Unlike the rector he serves, Edward preaches messages of substance, and always looks for ways to help the poor in his community. Agnes finds strength and encouragement in his sermons, and meets him during his rounds, when she is utilizing what little free time she has to help out some poor acquaintances. While it’s clear that Edward likes her, the young woman under her tutelage, Rosalie, grows jealous of the attention her governess receives, and embarks on a campaign to win the curate’s affections. But Edward, like Agnes, is firmly grounded in his principles. Events separate the two, and they lose contact for some time, but in the end, they recognize their mutual affection, marry, and embark together on their happily-ever-after.

As much as I enjoyed Mansfield Park, Pride And Prejudice offers more to the average reader, works on a number of levels, and justifiably deserves more praise. Similarly, when comparing the two novels, Agnes Grey never approaches the greatness of Wuthering Heights. Yet with its simple structure and style, we emerge with a satisfactory understanding of who Agnes is, what matters to her, and the society she inhabits. The novel doesn’t read like a fictionalized memoir, but as a tale in its own right.  And unlike Anne’s own life, which (like her sister Emily) ended in illness at a young age, we get to see Agnes amply rewarded for all the trials and tribulations she endured. 

If Agnes Grey can only labeled a classic because of Anne’s association with her sisters, then I’m grateful for that association. As with Jane Austen's novel Mansfield Park, sometimes it's nice to see the more sedate, less sensational stories win through and achieve immortality. Unlike all the countless stories that are destined to be forgotten, I’m glad this one is still remembered. Not because Agnes Grey was great, but because it was good. Really good. Not perfect, not spectacular, not thrilling. Just a nice, relaxing, straightforward, easy read. Sometimes, I need that. Perhaps, every once in a while, you do too.

Dragon Dave