Showing posts with label Sherlock Holmes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sherlock Holmes. Show all posts

Monday, August 6, 2018

Arthur Conan Doyle in Princetown and Cromer


Visit Dartmoor National Park in England, and you'll see the desolate landscape Sherlock Holmes braved in The Hound of the Baskervilles. Travel to the town of Princetown, deep within this brooding landscape, and you'll see the prison from which the murderer Seldon escaped to terrorize the local inhabitants. Stop by the Dartmoor National Park High Moorland Visitor Centre, and you'll see the great detective himself, along with the terrible black hound that haunted the Baskerville family.

It was here that Arthur Conan Doyle stayed a century ago, when the visitor center was the Rowe Duchy Hotel. From there, he investigated the claims of his friend, journalist Fletcher Robinson, who told him of about the Black Shuck, a dark, spectral beast that prowled the lonely moors, looking for souls to devour.


Travel north, to the seaside town of Cromer in the county of Norfolk, and you'll see where Fletcher Robinson first told Arthur Conan Doyle about the Black Shuck. The two were visiting Cromer for a golfing holiday, when Robinson told Doyle about the legendary Black Shuck that had haunted the good people of Norfolk for centuries. 

According to researchers, Arthur Conan Doyle transformed Dartmoor's Fox Tor Mire into Grimpen Mire for The Hound of the Baskervilles. He transformed stories of a notorious Dartmoor lord of the manor, Richard Cabell of Brock Hall, into Hugo Baskerville. He even combined several large houses, so say Dartmoor historians, into Baskerville Hall. 




Historians in seaside Cromer disagree, at least with the latter. They point to Cromer Hall, a local manor house, as the inspiration for Baskerville Hall. They claim that descriptions in The Hound of the Baskervilles portray Cromer Hall, not some backward Dartmoor manor house. 

Did an evil lord of Cromer Hall once live to hunt and terrorize the peasantry? Was this wicked aristocrat killed by the ghostly Black Shuck, whose fearsome howls could be heard across the land at night? And does the Black Shuck still roam Cromer and Dartmoor?

If you visit either place, and the wind sweeps over the land, then you'll know.

Dragon Dave


Thursday, December 22, 2016

Traveling with H.G. Wells, Jane Austen, and Arthur Conan Doyle

In November, I read several graphic novels, lots of comics, and a book on geology. I also read three novels. The first, by H. G. Wells, transported me to Switzerland. Or, at least, so it seemed. 

Supposedly, A Modern Utopia takes place on a planet like Earth in another solar system, but the descriptions of the landscape, and the picturesque villages, reminded me of Switzerland. In many ways, it reminded me of one of his earlier novels, The Wheels of Chance. In that novel, his protagonist, a young draper, sets off on a bicycle holiday in the south of England. His descriptions of the landscape are so vivid, so evocative, and so overwhelmingly beautiful that it made me want to follow the hero's bicycle journey with my wife. In A Modern Utopia, I felt as though he was transporting me to Switzerland. It's a country I would very much like to visit some day, and Wells spoke just as passionately about his surroundings in this idealized world as he did in The Wheels of Chance. 

After A Modern Utopia, Jane Austen returned me to some familiar sites in her novel Persuasion. The story begins in a manor house in Somerset, a county in southern England. In fact, it's the same county in which the real-life manor in the TV series To The Manor Born is located. 


As in the TV series, Austen's protagonist Anne, through no fault of her own, is forced to leave her beloved country home due to the fiscal mismanagement of a family member: in this case, her father. So she travels to stay with a family friend, then another member of her family, and this second visit takes her to Lyme Regis. 




While she and her party tour the seaside resort, a crucial event in the story takes place on the Cobb. This is a long walkway or pier, and perhaps the town's most striking feature. 

Jane Austen's characters then make their way to Bath, a setting she used in Northanger Abbey, which I read in October. Sadly, she doesn't offer much description of Bath in Persuasion. Austen painted a more vibrant view of the historic city in Northanger Abbey. (Also, Charles Dickens set part of his first novel The Pickwick Papers there, which I read earlier this year). Still, reading about Anne's visit to Bath made me want to travel there. It was a fashionable resort town in Austen's time, and remains a popular town for tourists today.

Finally, I returned to England for The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes. This second collection of stories took me back to London, the great town's suburbs, and other towns in rural England. Then for the last story, "The Final Problem", Arthur Conan Doyle returned me to Switzerland, as Holmes and Watson seek to evade the clutches of the evil Professor Moriarty. As all Holmes aficionados know, Holmes and Moriarty have their final confrontation at a very real place: Reichenbach Falls. Having seen many dramatizations of this beloved story, I enjoyed reading Doyle's words, and following the characters' journey through Switzerland. 

Ah, the places great stories can take us!

Dragon Dave

Monday, January 18, 2016

Arthur Conan Doyle & The Other Side of Dartmoor

In Arthur Conan Doyle's novel The Hound of the Baskervilles, Dr John Watson describes Dartmoor Forest as a dark, dangerous, and wild place. This is largely the way we found it during our two days there last year. But there were a few exceptions to the rule, and one of those was in a Bed & Breakfast near Hay Tor.


Hay Tor is a cluster of boulders, strewn across the top of a fell in Dartmoor. The wind rushes up and over these small hills, or fells, battering your body and howling in your ears. But at our Bed & Breakfast near Hay Tor, the air was quiet and still. After continually getting inundated by the angry elements, I enjoyed wandering the grounds outside our room, and marvel at the beauty of the gardens.


I suppose part of the reason for this is that this little neighborhood was surrounded by trees, that form a natural windbreak, preventing the wind from rushing over this area and tearing their plants, bushes, and flowers to shreds. Had Baskerville Hall been surrounded by tall trees, Arthur Conan Doyle might have described the estate differently. Come to think of it, I believe Dr John Watson mentions a number of tall shrubs that formed barriers around the grounds, so perhaps these offered Baskerville Hall a little shelter from the wind. But then, Sir Henry only employed two servants, a butler and a cook. Had he employed a full-time gardener, perhaps Baskerville Hall could have enjoyed a more pleasant aspect.


I suspect Arthur Conan Doyle wished readers to see Baskerville Hall as dark and forbidding as the surrounding countryside. Of his four Sherlock Holmes novels, only one takes place in and around London. Half of the first novel, A Study in Scarlet, takes place in the wild western state of Utah, where cowboys drive cattle across the range, covered wagons bring settlers to untamed lands, and bandits pillage and murder those they encounter. Half of his final Sherlock Holmes novel, The Valley of Fear, takes place in a mining town in the United States. There, the local branch of a men's club has become the headquarters for organized crime. The men in this group steal from nonmembers, extort businesses, and beat and kill other residents in their lust for riches and power. So it makes sense that for his third novel, The Hound of the Baskervilles, Arthur Conan Doyle sought to make a Dartmoor Forest seem wild and forbidding to English readers. 


Given the way the elements had raged at us, my wife and I brought food with us, and planned on eating in our room that night. But the air was so still, the temperature so moderate, and our surroundings so beautiful, we enjoyed a pleasant, relaxing dinner at a picnic table outside our room. Which just goes to show that no matter how vividly an author describes a particular place, you really can't know what it's like until you actually visit. But then, isn't that a great reason to travel: to check out the places that inspired authors like Arthur Conan Doyle to use them as settings for their stories?

Dragon Dave

Monday, January 11, 2016

Arthur Conan Doyle: Punishment in Dartmoor

In his investigations, Sherlock Holmes sometimes allows a prisoner to escape capture. He regards it as his duty to solve the case, not catch the criminal. In Arthur Conan Doyle's novel The Hound of the Baskervilles, it is Dr. John Watson who allows a prisoner to go free. While staying at Baskerville Hall, Dr. Watson and Sir Henry Baskerville learn that the brother of a servant is hiding out on the moor. When they try to apprehend the fellow, the butler and his wife, Mr. and Mrs. Barrymore, intercede on the criminal's behalf. They beg the gentlemen to leave him alone for a few days, as they have secretly secured his passage aboard a ship traveling to South America.

While exploring the glories and dangers of Dartmoor, Arthur Conan Doyle stayed in the Duchy Hotel in Princetown, which now serves as the visitor center for Dartmoor National Park. 



There, Doyle doubtless heard shocking tales of the inhuman crimes for which inmates of the famous prison located on the outskirts of the town had been sentenced. Yet we mainly see Seldon, a dangerous escaped convict, through his sister's eyes. 

"Yes sir, my name was Selden, and he is my younger brother. We humored him too much when he was a lad, and gave him his way in everything until he came to think that the world was made for his pleasure, and that he could do what he liked in it. Then, as he grew older, he met wicked companions, and the devil entered into him until he broke his mother's heart and dragged our name in the dirt. From crime to crime he sank lower and lower, until it is only the mercy of God which has snatched him from the scaffold; but to me, sir, he was always the little curly-headed boy that I had nursed and played with, as an elder sister would."

The next day, rain covers the land, and Watson cannot help thinking of the convict out upon the bleak, cold, shelterless moor.

While visiting Dartmoor this summer, wearing long pants and a rain jacket proved mandatory. Winds howled across the barren landscape, and rainclouds sped across the land. The sheep and cattle grazing on the rocky ground seemed inured to their surroundings. But despite its rugged beauty, I couldn't imagine living in Dartmoor.

And that was during the summer, not during the hard autumn rains, or the bitter winter snowstorms.



Whatever Dr. John Watson, Sherlock Holmes, or Arthur Conan Doyle thought of England's prison system in the early twentieth century, I can sympathize with Watson's thoughts on anyone forced to live rough on the moor.

Poor fellow! Whatever his crimes, he has suffered something to atone for them.

Dragon Dave


Monday, January 4, 2016

Arthur Conan Doyle: Fatal Attraction



"It's gone!" said he. "The Mire has him. Two in two days, and many more, perhaps, for they get in the way of going there in the dry weather, and never know the difference until the Mire has them it its clutch."
--The Hound of the Baskervilles by Arthur Conan Doyle

Like Dr John Watson, we had our own encounter with the wild ponies of Dartmoor. Thankfully, it ended safely for all concerned. But it could have ended far more tragically.

As we drove along the narrow strips of tarmac that wound like ribbons through Dartmoor forest, we often saw ponies along the road. Usually, they ignored us as we slowed, steered around them, and continued on our way. But once they looked up, forsook their grass, and wandered over to meet us.

While one walked boldly toward us, another approached us from the side. The latter peered in through the window, as if he wished to converse with us.



When I shared our encounter with a local, she said that the greatest danger the ponies faced was human visitors. The wild ponies get used to the human visitors feeding them. Their visitors' kindness emboldens them with the expectation of more handouts. 

Unfortunately, sometimes the ponies wander onto the road before a passing car can stop. Some of the ponies we saw bore scars from their encounters with vehicles. Thankfully, we never saw results of this human/pony fatal attraction during our time there. 

I gather an initiative is underway to daub the ponies with reflective paint, after dozens of vehicle-related deaths this year. Hopefully, this will help the situation, particularly for visitors driving through Dartmoor at night. For, like Dr John Watson, no one wants to hear the mournful cry of a dying pony, echoing across the moors.

Dragon Dave

Related Internet Links
Dartmoor Ponies Daubed With Paint

Wednesday, December 16, 2015

Arthur Conan Doyle: Equine Fascination



Something brown was rolling and tossing among the green sedges. Then a long, agonized, writhing neck shot upwards and a dreadful cry echoed over the moor. It turned me cold with horror, but my companion's nerves seemed to be stronger than mine.

--Taken from The Hound of the Baskervilles by Arthur Conan Doyle.

Some people are fortunate enough to befriend our equine cousins. They raise horses, groom them, ride them, and really get to know them. The rest of us, the vast majority of humankind, look on from afar, and wonder what such relationships are like. We find it all too easy to ascribe general characteristics to them. 


We may stereotype donkeys and mules as irritable, disobedient, and general bad company. Even when they have our best interests at heart, as the Biblical prophet Balaam discovered when his donkey steered him away from an angel sent to kill him, still, they can't help but irritate their owners. 


Horses radiate tremendous power, but can prove standoffish and skittish. No matter how much we respect them, we learn to give them the expect they deserve. For all that power can backfire on their human friends. In one moment of passion, playfulness, or inattention, a horse can main or kill its owner.


Less powerful than their larger, more regal cousins, ponies possess the disarming ability to always appear cute and cuddly. One's heart readily goes out to ponies. They're so sweet, good-natured, and adorable, aren't they? How terrible that they must wander alone across the moors!


What better way could Arthur Conan Doyle demonstrate the dangers of Dartmoor, than by the land itself claiming the life of one of those cute, adorable ponies?




For proof of this, visit Dartmoor Forest. Search for the wild ponies, and when you find them, you will most likely see people nearby. "Quick honey, grab the camera." "Oh, what a poor creature!"  "I wonder if it needs something to eat?" "Oh, aren't you a beautiful little fellow?"


Just watch your step when you explore Dartmoor in search of ponies. Or, like the poor brown pony Dr John Watson saw, you may find the very ground beneath you desires nourishment. And other walkers may hear a dreadful cry echoing over the moor.


Dragon Dave

Monday, December 14, 2015

Arthur Conan Doyle on the Devil and Hellhounds


Folk tales of the devil riding through the forest on a magnificent black steed, leading a pack of hellish hounds, prompted Arthur Conan Doyle to visit Dartmoor Forest in Devon, England. It was there he would later send Sherlock Holmes and Dr John Watson in The Hound of the Baskervilles. A hellish hound certainly features in the novel, and seems perfectly at home amid a landscape of such wild and rugged beauty. But it is not the devil, nor a magnificent black horse, that personifies Dartmoor's beautiful but dangerous character in his classic story. Instead, it is the carefree, inoffensive ponies that wander the moor.

One day, Dr Watson steps outside of Baskerville Hall to take a walk across the moors. Hearing the approaching footsteps, Watson turns to see a small, slim man carrying a butterfly net. The naturalist introduces himself as Jack Stapleton, a former schoolmaster. As they talk, Stapleton warns Watson of the dangers of wandering alone through the countryside. 

"Only yesterday I saw one of the moor ponies wander into it. He never came out. I saw his head for quite a long time craning out of a bog-hole, but it sucked him down at last. Even in dry seasons it is a danger to cross it, but after these autumn rains it is an awful place. And yet I can find my way to the very heart of it and return alive. By George, there is another of those miserable ponies!"

There's a reason that Arthur Conan Doyle paints Dartmoor as a dark, forbidding place. It's a windswept stretch of gently rolling hills, or fells. Crowning these rises are wild grasses, spindly shrubs, and trees bent by the winds that howl over the land. Or at least, that's how we found it, when my wife and I visited this year.



Did I mention that we visited there in summer?

Nearly everywhere else we went in Devon and Cornwall, I wore shorts. But long pants, a thick shirt, a windbreaker, and a knitted hat proved essential to battle the winds that screamed in your ears and threatened to freeze you from exposure. (Try wearing a baseball cap, and the winds will tear it off your head!) I imagine residents adore Dartmoor's unique beauty in winter, but I can't imagine living there in the summer, let alone during the colder seasons. 

No wonder folktales of Dartmoor feature the devil and hellhounds. But what place could be more evil, than a forest that regularly claims the lives of sweet, adorable ponies?

Dragon Dave 

Wednesday, November 11, 2015

Sherlock Holmes' Expenses in The Hound of the Baskervilles

Sherlock Holmes & the dreaded hound
in Princetown, Devon

In The Hound of the Baskervilles by Arthur Conan Doyle, Henry Baskerville is staying in a hotel in the Charing Cross region of London when he receives a letter warning him not to travel to Baskerville Hall in Devonshire, England. Only one word in the letter was handwritten. The rest were clipped from a newspaper, apparently with nail scissors, and affixed to the foolscap paper with gum. From their distinctive type (or font), Sherlock Holmes identifies the words as having been clipped from the inside page of yesterday's Times. Holmes wishes to determine where the paper might have been sent from. So he instructs a boy named Cartwright to visit all twenty-three hotels near the one in which Henry Baskerville is staying. At each, he is to give the outside porter one shilling, and tell the man he wishes to see yesterday's waste paper. 

In each case, the outside porter will send for the hall porter, to whom also you will give a shilling. 

Holmes gives the boy an additional ten shillings, in case he encounters any unforeseen expenses.

In all, Holmes is entrusting the boy with two pounds and eighty pence. This may not seem like a lot in today's money, but it's probably equivalent to what the boy earned for a six-day work week, working ten hours a day. Apparently the boy showed some ability during a prior investigation. On this occasion however, young Cartwright could find no copies of yesterday's Times with parts of the second page cut out. 

After Henry Baskerville left 221B Baker Street, Holmes and Watson followed him. As he hoped, Holmes spotted a man with a beard following Baskerville in a hansom cab. Holmes contacts the cab company, and the driver later visits him. Holmes offers the man half a sovereign if he can tell him the name of the man with the beard. 

"His name," said the cabman, "was Mr. Sherlock Holmes."

For a moment Holmes sat in silent amazement. Then he burst into a hearty laugh.

I've no idea how much the cabdriver earned after expenses, but he was so concerned about his reputation that he visited Holmes when he learned of his inquiry. Yet he readily tells Holmes about his charge when Holmes offers him a half-sovereign, which equates to a half-pound. All total, Holmes has now spent three pounds and thirty pence on his investigation on Henry Baskerville's behalf. I wonder what that might equate to in today's money, don't you?

The investigation will prove much more expensive, as Holmes sends out Watson to stick by Henry's side while he stays at Baskerville Hall. And then Holmes will have many more expenses in research, sending wires (telegrams), food, and travel. It makes me wonder how much Holmes earned in comparison to other classes of people in London at the turn of the twentieth century. He certainly dresses well, and lives in an apartment in the heart of the city. And he has enough to send Watson out to purchase a pound of the strongest shag tobacco on the first day of the investigation, all of which he smokes while considering whether or not to take the Baskerville case.

Thankfully, Sherlock Holmes smoked so heavily before tobacco caused lung cancer. Unfortunately, that's no longer the case today. While I may not understand the value of wages and the cost of living in 1901, we all know what the cost of lung cancer is today, don't we?

Dragon Dave

Thursday, February 20, 2014

Addicted To Sherlock Holmes


A while ago, I had a pastor who was a Sherlock Holmes buff. Not only did he know the original Arthur Conan Doyle stories inside-and-out, but he read novels written by other authors, including ones in which the famous detective moves to America, or investigates crimes in the present era.  At the time, I found this odd: Sherlock Holmes resettles in the United States?  A Sherlock Holmes that works in the present, using a computer and cell phone?  But back then, Sherlock Holmes began and ended for me with the TV series starring Jeremy Brett, which seemed like faithful dramatizations of the original Doyle stories.  

For whatever reason, every time I sat down to read Doyle's stories, I had trouble doing so.  But I enjoyed the Sherlock Holmes TV and movie adaptations, so I sought more out.  While I liked the recent Guy Richie films, my favorite adaptations were the faithful ones, such as the old TV series starring Peter Cushing.  But then I discovered the Basil Rathbone movies, which had Sherlock Holmes uncovering plots involving Nazis during the World War II era.   And then there was the Herbert Ross film "The Seven-Per-Cent Solution."  That movie, while rich in humor, also tackled the issue of Sherlock Holmes' drug-use head-on.  Holmes is so addled by drugs that Watson eventually takes him to see Sigmund Freud, so that the famous psychoanalyst can help cure his addiction.

When I heard about "Elementary" being set in modern-day New York, with a woman playing Watson, I didn't believe it could work.  Yet the series gradually sucked me in, and as the first season rolled along, I grew so enamored that I wrote a few blog posts about it.  Now, well into the second season, my fervor for the show is no less strong.  In fact, I recently started watching the first season on DVD, and watching the episodes quickly became compulsive activity.  One episode just wasn't enough!

Like "The Seven-Per-Cent Solution," the series delves into the topic of Sherlock Holmes' drug use.  In London, Sherlock helps Scotland Yard investigate a string of bizarre serial murders.  The killer strings his victims up in their homes, drains them of blood, and then disposes of their bodies elsewhere.  One day he meets Irene Adler.  Her intelligence, personality, and capabilities astound him.  He never believed that he could meet a woman that fulfilled him so completely, and his love for her grows by the hour.  Irene seems to share his feelings, and find more in common with him than any other person she has ever met.  Day passes after blissful day, until one evening Sherlock arrives at her apartment to find a letter from the serial killer he's been pursuing, and a pool of blood. Heart-broken, blaming himself for her death, an occasional experimentation with drugs grows into something more.  As a result, Scotland Yard refuses to allow him to assist in that or any other investigation.  Traumatized and isolated by his emotions, his career in tatters, and robbed of the woman who once fulfilled him, his descent into drugs becomes total.  

Eventually, he washes up in New York City.

There he meets Watson.  She recently gave up her career as a surgeon, because she blamed herself for the death of one of her patients.  She now works as a sober companion, and Holmes' father back in England engages her services.  So she moves into Sherlock's brownstone, periodically tests his blood, counsels him on how to handle situations that might trigger drug use, and accompanies him as he consults on cases for the NYPD.  Up until now, she has found her new occupation unfulfilling.  But Sherlock Holmes' unique view of the world, and his capabilities as an investigator, confound her.  She rises to this challenge, and offers him advice and suggestions based on her extensive medical knowledge.  

Sherlock's resistance to her constant presence (and unwanted counsel) lessens as he finds his powers of deduction strengthened by her insights, and their investigations fill the void created when she abandoned her medical career.  Her assistance increases as she begins to think like him, extending beyond sheer medical areas, and her ways of reacting to the world rub off on him.  When her period of being a sober companion ends, she finds herself reluctant to move on and care for the next recovering addict, and Sherlock invites her to stay on as his assistant.  Under his tutelage, she becomes a competent detective in her own right, whose aid is likewise valued by the police.  Ultimately, as Season One winds down, summoning up with it the ghost of Irene Adler, it is a suggestion from Watson that allows Sherlock to help the NYPD capture his old nemesis Moriarty.  

Suddenly reality intrudes, and I realize that I've watched all the episodes of Season One.  Now I must sustain myself on the occasional new broadcast episode until Season Two is released.  If only I could fast-forward in time, and receive that DVD set tomorrow.  For despite being set in contemporary New York, with Sherlock Holmes a tech-savvy recovering drug addict, and accompanied by a female Watson, "Elementary" seems to have become the best TV adaptation of Sherlock Holmes I've ever seen!

Maybe I'd better give those Arthur Conan Doyle stories another try.

Dragon Dave

Related Dragon Cache entries
John Hannah and Sherlock Holmes Play With Drugs
Sherlock Holmes Plays With Sticks

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Sherlock Holmes Plays With Sticks


An Episcopal priest once told me he regarded “Fight Club” as one of the most noteworthy movies of the twentieth century.  Not having seen it, I couldn't respond, although the topic seemed an odd choice for a priest (even an Episcopal one) to espouse.  More recently, my father-in-law took issue with Guy Ritchie’s “Sherlock Holmes” movies.  He saw them as too rough-and-tumble, celebrating violence far more than a proper adaptation should.

While reading The Blotting Book by E. F. Benson, I came across a reference to single-stick fighting.  I learned that this was a form of dueling popular during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century.  Participants would wield a three-foot-long, one-inch-thick dowel at each other instead of a foil or sword, and any blows above the waist were allowed.  The objective—the game-ending blow, you might say—was to strike your opponent in the head with sufficient strength to draw blood.  Imagine my surprise when I learned that Arthur Conan Doyle describes Sherlock Holmes as a skilled, single-stick fighter!

I fell in love with Sherlock Holmes from Jeremy Brett’s interpretation of the character.  His Holmes seemed so cerebral, and the TV shows followed the popular conception of Doyle’s stories, in which Holmes relates his adventures to Dr. John Watson in the comfort of his sedate sitting room.  Holmes prizes intellect above all, and naturally downplays the physical aspects of any caper.  As in the latest movies, he’s a formidable bare-fist fighter.  And, as Victorian London was anything but safe and peaceful, gentlemen of that era typically carried a walking stick.  Well, Sherlock Holmes knew how to defend himself with that item as well.

I agree with my father-in-law.  Just as “The Seven-Per-Cent Solution” and “Elementary” portray Holmes as addicted (or having been addicted) to drugs, the Guy Ritchie movies hype the action, as if to suggest that Holmes pursues detective work because he is addicted to action, adventure, and violence.  Such portrayals show Sherlock Holmes as a vulnerable character, and make him more relatable to today’s audience.  But I think that part of Sherlock Holmes’ popularity must stem from his perceived invulnerability.  In Arthur Conan Doyle’s stories, Holmes not only out-thinks his opponents, he can hold his own in a fight, and he can even experiment with dangerous drugs without growing addicted.  He is, in every sense of the word, a superior man.


Given my recent discovery of the sport in The Blotting Book, in was neat to see Holmes teaching Watson single-stick fighting in last week’s episode of “Elementary.”  This depiction of Holmes' sidekick may diverge farther from Doyle's original than any previous adaptation, but I like Joan Watson.  She has intellect and spunk, and even without Holmes' instruction, has demonstrated that she can defend herself when necessary.  

She’s a tough lady, this Watson.

Dragon Dave

Thursday, February 14, 2013

John Hannah and Sherlock Holmes Play With Drugs


The movie, “The Seven-Per-Cent Solution,” portrays a Sherlock Holmes so befuddled by drugs that Watson is able to trick him into traveling to Austria, in order to be cured by the great Sigmund Freud.  The TV series “Elementary” takes a different look at the connection between Sherlock Holmes and drug usage.  Watson, a former surgeon, lives with him in New York City as a sober companion, forcing Holmes, fresh out of drug rehabilitation, to attend meetings for former addicts.  Of course, while he is learning to live without relying on drugs, Holmes also consults with the NYPD on their most perplexing cases.

In last week’s episode, “A Giant Gun, Filled With Drugs,” a former drug dealer, Rhys (pronounced “Reese,” and played by our good friend John Hannah, from "The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor") shows up at Holmes’ apartment.  His daughter has been kidnapped, and Holmes immediately bursts into action, evaluating all available evidence.  Watson asks Rhys how he’s “keeping it together,” and Rhys says that he’s observed Holmes back in London.  He watched Holmes draw conclusions from seemingly random data at superhuman speed, and responds with a smile, “I believe in Sherlock Holmes.” 


Rhys is under a deadline to pay the ransom demand, and when complications ensue, he begins to question his unswerving faith.  He tells Holmes, “I’m proud of you.  It must be like trying to relearn the piano after a stroke, doing what you do, without the drugs.”  Holmes says “Ridiculous,” and asserts that he’s engaged in a deductive science.  “Drugs are a hindrance, not a help.”  But Rhys says that part of what Holmes does, making connections, involves the creative and artistic side of his brain.  “Some artists need the drugs to fuel the creative stuff,” he tells Holmes.  Rhys argues that some artists, such as rock musicians, have often produced their best work while under the influence.  


After a particularly troubling setback, Rhys offers Holmes cocaine.  Holmes, enraged, hurls Rhys into a chair.  “You’ve needed it these last two days,” Rhys tells him.  “Listen to the rubbish you’ve been spouting.  That’s not you; that’s not Sherlock Holmes.  This is some ghost of you, some pale imitation.  You need your meds, get yourself right.”  

There may be some truth to Rhys’ assertion.  Some drugs may temporarily boost a person’s creativity.  Sadly, in the long term, we also know that they damage the brain.  As Rhys suggests, some artists, after going sober, have found it difficult to equal the quality of their earlier, drug-influenced work.  Imagine what that must feel like, to listen or look at something you created, something you made, and wonder if you’ll ever achieve that level of performance or brilliance again.  Up until now, Holmes has steadfastly denied the necessity of Watson’s role in his life.  While forced to attend meetings for former addicts, he has refused to share his own experiences with drugs.  But at the end of the episode, he asks Watson if they can delay dinner so he can attend one such meeting.  He says that he wants to share his experience, saying off-hand, “Others may find inspiration in my abstinence.”

I’ve provided a link at the bottom, so you can watch the episode if you like.  For those who prefer not to, know that Holmes validates Rhys’ faith in him.  When Rhys tells Holmes, one last time, “I believe in ya,” he’s not saying he believes in The Man-Plus-Drugs.  This time, he really believes in Sherlock Holmes.

Believe in yourself.

Dragon Dave

Related Internet Links

"Elementary" airs on CBS on Thursday evenings.  I'll be watching tonight's episode.  How about you?