Showing posts with label Terra Nova. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Terra Nova. Show all posts

Friday, February 17, 2012

Protecting Our Dinosaurs


One of the worst criticisms a reviewer can level against a Science Fiction novel is to state that the characters and setting fail to undergo significant and lasting change.  This is because they see Science Fiction as the type of literature that most celebrates diversity and change.  Whether the characters fight off alien invaders, or work to prevent a mad scientist from profoundly changing the world, they argue that if the characters and setting revert to their former status at story's end, the book does not deserve to be labeled Science Fiction.  Instead, it belongs to a subset of mainstream literature with watered-down SF elements, and is referred to as a thriller, or described as merely SFnal.  While I understand such arguments, I cannot accept such a narrow definition of the fiction I love.

In the 1960s, the Doctor Who production team underwent a series of changes.  Producers and Script Supervisors came and went, in some cases after a single story.  At one point, those in charge decided that the first Doctor, William Hartnell, must leave the program, and drafted in Patrick Troughton as his replacement.  Those in charge of production during this later era largely abandoned the historical stories, and the stories tended to focus upon the Doctor defeating fearsome aliens and scary monsters.  Such a narrow focus took its toll.  By the end of the second Doctor’s reign, the BBC considered canceling the show.  Thankfully, they opted to continue, and injected new life into the program by grounding the Doctor on Earth.  Surrounded by Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart and the United Nations Intelligence Taskforce (UNIT), the third Doctor occasionally traveled to other planets, but mostly fought to unravel the plots of mad scientists, or to prevent aliens from invading Earth.  More than in any other incarnation, either previous or successive, the third Doctor (played by Jon Pertwee) worked to prevent significant change.  This was the role he played in the story “Invasion of the Dinosaurs,” when he seeks to prevent the conspirators from activating their Timescoop a final time.  As much as he admires their vision of a more eco-friendly civilization, he cannot agree with their methods.  For while their device would protect everyone and everything within the immediate area as it transports the group and their supplies back to the time of the dinosaurs, not only would it eradicate those unprotected by the Timescoop, but also erase every person who has ever lived.

The colonists in “Terra Nova” face a similar challenge.  They cannot exert significant change upon their surroundings.  They must prevent any citizen, or breakaway group such as the Sixers, from decimating a particular species of animal or plant, over-utilizing any of the world’s resources, or polluting their environment.  To fail in this, or to prevent any industrialists from time-traveling back and wiping out such Paleozoic resources could bring catastrophic results.  In addition to destroying the colony’s long-term sustainability, such profound change could wreak havoc upon the timeline, wiping out or significantly altering all of human history.  Should this occur, their link to the future would be forever severed.  They would find themselves without access to modern technology, medicine, and other goods that allow them to share this world with the dinosaurs that rule the planet.  No more pilgrimages would join them.  They would be forever alone.

Lovejoy understands such concepts better than most.  His love for mankind’s unique creations is unparalleled.  In the TV series, and in the novels by Jonathan Gash, this dealer works to protect antiques from undergoing any change whatsoever.  He would be outraged if asked to modernize a centuries-old desk fashioned by a master craftsman.  He would be aghast if a client cleaned an antique without proper guidance.  He knows that the wrong chemicals, applied in an incorrect manner, can weaken or eradicate the unique patina bestowed upon wood, canvas, or other materials by time, leaving the artwork little different from today’s copies or reproductions.  This, like the third Doctor and Commander Taylor in Terra Nova, makes Lovejoy someone whose existence revolves around the prevention of change.  

We grow angry when our plans for change are dismissed.  Yet sometimes we should sit back and reflect upon the possible wisdom of those who work to prevent such changes from occurring.  For as grand as our visions might be, any change impacts others and affects our environment.  And all of us can be brittle, many times in ways we’re not aware of.  To alter or eradicate the dinosaurs upon which we depend might hurt us in significant ways, or even destroy us.  Sometimes, those who work to prevent any change from occurring are the most visionary of all.  


Related Dragon Cache entries

Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Preserving Our Dinosaurs


Imagine air so foul that you must wear a respirator whenever you leave your apartment.  You press through crowded, darkened streets—little sunlight pierces the polluted air.  The government limits every aspect of your life, from the food you eat to the number of children you’re allowed to have.  Good luck finding a job, let alone one that fulfills your passion: you compete with your fellow citizens for the few on offer, knowing the slightest offense or poor test result can make you unemployable.  Am I describing life in a communist state?  Am I imagining the lives of the European poor prior to WWI?  No, I’m thinking of the future as depicted in the recent TV series “Terra Nova.”  This is the future the conspirators in the “Doctor Who” story “Invasion of the Dinosaurs” fear is inevitable.  It is a future Earth exhausted by too many bold visions, too many dynamic changes, and too many revisions of the existing order.

Change is inevitable.  Every day brings new demands.  Today’s bold solutions and “improvements” to yesterday’s way of life, necessary though they seem, inevitably lead to fresh challenges that must be tackled.  Therefore we prize innovation highly.  We praise inventors.  We herald visionary leaders who propose sweeping reforms.  We pride ourselves when our government funds the programs we see as necessary, or cuts the programs we see as wasteful.  Yet each change is like a stone tossed into a pond.  Throw in too many, and not only do we disturb the water, but we elevate the bottom of the pool until it grows level with the surrounding land.  Wind and sunlight dry the damp ground, erasing all signs of the former pond.  To preserve our pool, we cannot throw in too many stones, and we must occasionally dredge it to prevent the bottom from rising too high.  So which stones should we not throw in?  Which stones should we remove when we dredge the pool?  On what basis do we make such decisions?

As much as we yearn for bold change and gentle revisions, we also long for stability.  We contribute to social security, healthy insurance, and pension systems in the belief that these companies and government departments will care for us in the future.  We draw up contracts to ensure that each party delivers the promised goods, services, and monies.  We join faith communities and groups that celebrate our views and values, and feel betrayed if the leadership later revises the existing orthodoxy.  We loving maintain our favorite automobiles, clothing, furniture, and artwork to lengthen their useful lives.  We saddle ourselves with hefty mortgage payments, take all necessary measures to ensure we can live out our lives in them, and pray that the government or our family won’t force us from our beloved homes in our twilight years.  We engage in marriage, the ultimate in long-term contracts, in the hopes that we will share the rest of our lives with our loving partner.  We expend effort and give to groups that pledge to protect certain plant and animal species against extinction.  We recycle, buy ecofriendly products, and try to utilize as little gas and electricity as we can, because we wish to bequeath a healthy world to future generations.  Stability: oh how we crave it!

We embrace change in certain areas of our lives, but seek to protect other areas against any change whatsoever.  We welcome the extinction of those dinosaurs we despise, turn a blind eye to the carcasses of others’ cherished beliefs and institutions, but cry foul when the creaking old agreements, definitions, and viewpoints we love are threatened.  How do we balance the change we feel we need with the stability we crave?  How do we protect others’ dinosaurs when we see their existence as antithetical to our own?  Some things we know must be changed, others can be changed, and some, we believe, must never be changed. Where do we draw the line between compulsion and compassion, and who defines which of our cherished dinosaurs reside in either category?  

Sometimes I am bewildered by how oblivious others are to my feelings, my expectations, and my beliefs.  Each day I strive for perfect vision that will allow me to view others’ needs as equal to my own.  I know this is impossible.  Yet I try.  For one thing I know.  Whether I see the future depicted in “Terra Nova” as metaphorical or literal, I want to live there even less than I wish to colonize Earth in the Triassic, Jurassic, or Cretaceous Periods.  I want to live right here, right now, and I don’t want anyone to threaten the dinosaurs I cherish with extinction.

The moral of this story: Don’t you dare mess with my pet Triceratops!


This series will conclude with "Protecting Our Dinosaurs."


Related Dragon Cache entries

Thursday, February 9, 2012

Renewing our Dinosaurs


Have you ever wondered why a particular show never caught on with the viewing public?  With its dinosaurs that looked like puppets, the “Doctor Who” story “Invasion of the Dinosaurs” earned the fan’s disdain.  The same criticism cannot be made of the digital creations in last year’s series “Terra Nova,” which surely belong alongside the most convincing ever brought to our television screens.  Yet the future of the show seems in doubt, as ratings were not high enough for executives to readily agree to the production costs of a second season.  Given humanity’s eternal fascination with dinosaurs, I’ve wondered why more people aren’t tuning in.  Perhaps part of the reason lies in the series’ underlying premise: that man’s increasing demands upon the environment have ruined the Earth beyond hope of renewal.  

Perhaps the human brain is programmed to reject the idea that our world is capable of being destroyed.  We know that an asteroid or comet could strike the Earth tomorrow. Movies such as “Armageddon,” and novels such as Shiva Descending by Gregory Benford and William Rotsler, portray the catastrophic effects such an event would bring mankind.  Yet the United States doesn’t even have a craft capable of manned spaceflight at the moment, let alone the means of deflecting such an object.  We know that Carbon Dioxide levels are rising dangerously high.  Movies such as “The Day After Tomorrow,” and novels such as Forty Signs of Rain by Kim Stanley Robinson, remind us that Global Warming could wipe out many of the plants and animals we depend upon, and make the climate inhospitable for us.  Yet instead of taking bold steps and sweeping action to combat these threats, we argue over the necessity of taking any action whatsoever. 

As much as we sometimes yearn to wipe the slate clean and begin again, we often prefer minor alterations to existing routines.  Rather than destroying and building something completely different, we embrace revision and renewal.  In the TV series, and the novels by Jonathan Gash, Lovejoy not only locates antiques for clients, but also restores them to their former glory.  Where others see ruin, he perceives a return to glory.  Our TVs and shelves are swamped with shows and books that enable us to restore old furniture, or alter it to suit current demands.  For every building we demolish to build another, many more are added-onto, rebuilt, or remodeled.  Mechanics rebuild or modernize old cars, even if the result costs more in money and time than purchasing the current model.  Instead of penning a new story, writers often revisit unfinished manuscripts in the hopes of finally capturing their initial conceptions.  Rather than opting for divorce and starting with another, spouses persist in their attempts to reinvigorate an ailing marriage, regardless of how broken their relationship might seem to others.  We restore, rebuild, remodel, rewrite, and refuse to believe that anything we love is ever completely beyond our ability to save.

I hope we eventually tackle the really big issues, such as the colonization of space (both to increase our knowledge and to ensure our species’ survival) and the reduction of Carbon Dioxide in our environment.  But I take heart in what I can do today, even if my individual concerns seem wholly unrelated to such global issues.  Even if what I accomplish is no more than a gentle reform, or a minor adaptation to a previous effort.  For who knows what all our individual changes, improvements, and upgrades might eventually accomplish?  Perhaps if all of us concentrate upon giving our best efforts in all that we do, and each day attempt to fulfill our ultimate potential, our individual efforts might add up to a new reality in which we perceive achievable solutions to such global threats. 

We often argue over causes and methods, or lay the blame for a particular problem at another’s door, and then conclude that a particular problem is unsolvable.  Is it any wonder that we  occasionally do battle with despair?  Yet, just as we reject the conspirators’ viewpoint in “Invasion of the Dinosaurs,” we reject the future as depicted in “Terra Nova.”  I find this tremendously encouraging.  For as special and unique as I may (or may not) be, or how strong and capable I may (or may not) be, I know that I don’t want to live on a ruined Earth.  And as cool as I think dinosaurs are, I don’t really want Mr. T. Rex as my next-door neighbor.  

Related Dragon Cache entries

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

The Allure of the Dinosaurs


I recently watched a TV show about a group of people who wished to relocate not to another part of the world, but back in time.  Freed from such current problems as political corruption, false ideologies, inner-city violence, and pollution, they would found fairer institutions, pursue social equality, and place less stress upon the environment.  In the time of the dinosaurs, they would reinvent the human condition.  Theirs would be an enlightened culture.  Man would strive to perfect himself in every way, while preserving the planet upon which he depended.  No, I’m not talking about last year’s series “Terra Nova,” but a program broadcast nearly forty years ago.

In the 1974 “Doctor Who” story “Invasion of the Dinosaurs,” the Tardis materializes in present day London.  As in “The Dalek Invasion of Earth,” the city seems largely deserted.  Places usually crowded with people, such as Trafalgar Square and the Victoria Embankment, are empty.  At least the forces patrolling the city are not Daleks and Robomen, but UNIT (the United Nations Intelligence Taskforce) and the British Army.  Using their Timescoop, this group of would-be settlers has brought a few dinosaurs forward in time.  Now, with the streets cleared and the military distracted by the dinosaurs, they can finish assembling what they need.  Then they will transport themselves, and everything they wish to take with them, back in time to found their new world.  

One can certainly understand the allure of starting over.  This is a common theme in the social, cultural, religious, and political arenas.  Robert Heinlein envisioned an entire generation’s yearning to reboot society in Stranger in a Strange Land.  Yet long before the 1960s, groups such as the Puritans, the Quakers, the Shakers, and the Amish developed their own unique ways of dealing with the world.  In many cases they got their start in the “New World,” where ordinary citizens fought a revolutionary war against the seemingly undefeatable British military to create the new government they desired: a representative democracy.  

The dream of rebooting society never fades, whether in the 1776, 1974 or today.  Politicians often win their way into office promising sweeping change and bold reform.  Scientists and engineers regularly invent items such as television, cellphones, and computers that profoundly change how we interact with others.  As a species, we keep embracing the “new way of doing things,” the “better idea,” the “superior” religion or philosophy or worldview.  In doing so we bring down the dinosaurs—once so strong and indomitable—that our sweeping change and bold reforms replace.  

The conspirators in “Invasion of the Dinosaurs” and the pilgrims in “Terra Nova” face the ultimate challenge.  If they can master such dangerous beasts, then perhaps they can sweep humanity’s former mistakes aside and begin anew.  But those of us in the present face no lesser task.  A former generation’s inventions, ideologies or structures may not address today's needs.  Working together, we can accomplish sweeping change and bold reform.  Looking inward, we can question what habits or viewpoints threaten to shipwreck our dreams, destroy our relationships with others, or cut short our lives.  

Perhaps that is why we seem endlessly fascinated by dinosaurs.  They remind us of the greatness of yesterday, while spurring us to meet the demands of today, and thus build our dreams for tomorrow.


Or maybe we just think they’re cool.

“Invasion of the Dinosaurs,” written by Malcolm Hulke, is available as a book, an audiobook, or on DVD from the BBC.  Hopefully, Fox will renew “Terra Nova” for a second season.  Robert Heinlein’s Stranger in a Strange Land is available in its traditional version as a Mass Market Paperback, or in a “complete, uncut” length as a Trade Paperback.  

Related Dragon Cache entries