Showing posts with label Locus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Locus. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Glen Cook, Important Fantasy Writer: Part 1


I saw Glen Cook at the 2006 World Fantasy Convention in Austin Texas, where he was a Guest of Honor.  At the time, I simply couldn’t understand it.  I’ve read Science Fiction and Fantasy (SF&F) all my life.  At the time, I had been reading “Locus Magazine,” the monthly magazine that reviewed the SF&F literary market, for over ten years.  Yet I had never heard of him.  Glen Cook: Guest of Honor?  He couldn’t be that important, could he?

As the World Fantasy Convention is geared toward published authors, few sat in on more than one panel discussion, and many didn’t even snag a seat.  Yet because he was a Guest of Honor, Glen Cook sat in on several, giving attendees his opinion on the various topics being discussed.  Often one of his fellow panelists would turn toward him and say, “You know, Glen, I’ve read some of your Black Company novels, and I really enjoyed them,” as if wishing to go on record that he, and that series, were significant.  But when I saw Glen Cook at his table in the dealer’s room, the books arrayed before him sported not the dark, ominous artwork of the Black Company series, but lighthearted scenes featuring an overcoat-clad detective.  How could he have written that many books in a series without my having heard about him? I wondered.  When my wife bought Sweet Silver Blues, the first installment in what I came to learn was his Garrett P.I. series, I asked her why she had purchased it.  After all, the organizers had given each of us a bag of books at registration, and we would have to pack them into our suitcases for the flight home.

“It just looked fun,” she told me.


As I’ve followed the SF&F literary market over the years, I’ve begun to realize that no reader can possibly stay on top of everything that’s out there.  The publishers put out too many titles each month, and bookstores play it safe by buying multiple copies of the latest offering by top selling authors, and a smattering of anything else that seems different enough that it might become the next big thing.  Even older, established authors find that bookstores carry no more than a small percentage of their available titles.  Consequently, lots of authors go unnoticed, and book reviewers who promote authors who constantly attempt to challenge reader’s expectations through their fiction only perpetuate this trend.  The longer I study the market, the more confounded I am by this approach.  For most readers aren’t looking to have their expectations of Fiction challenged or overthrown each time they pick up a novel.  They’ve worked hard all day, or spent too many hours studying.  They want an escape from reality, not literature that will place additional demands on their already fatigued brains and bodies. 

After my wife read Sweet Silver Blues, the first Garrett P.I. novel, I read it too.  I wasn’t won over by it.  The novel combines two normally separate genres, the High Fantasy novel, with its fantastical creatures, swordplay, and magic-wielding sorcerers and witches, with a Mystery novel featuring a stereotypical hardboiled detective.  Cook’s minimal description of Garrett’s world prevented me from envisioning his Fantasy world.  His characters, variations on traditional trolls, elves, and dwarves, prevented me from taking the overall mystery plot seriously.  Yet as is sometimes the case, that isn’t the end of the story.  Sometimes you discover a particular author before you’re ready for him, and sometimes the authors that prove important to you are different from those the reviewers say you should care about.

Tomorrow, I’ll tell you why you should care about Glen Cook’s novels.  Or at least why I do…now.

Dragon Dave

Saturday, February 9, 2013

Hungarian Folktales and a Changing Publishing Market


In Folktales of Hungary, Linda Degh demonstrates the importance of Folktales to the Hungarian poor.  Great importance was placed on the overall form of each story.  Individual storytellers were allowed to embroider, but audiences demanded they retain the key elements of any story.  Thus, while researchers might discover hundreds of variations, they could identify which particular story a person was telling.

Folktales preserved a community’s identity.  Legends explained unique aspects of a village or group.  Stories intermixed the religious and secular, as to a certain extent, both were seen as controlling and oppressive.  Parents instilled the culture’s most important stories in their children, so that as they grew older, they would be able to relate the basics of each story.  An essential part of family gatherings involved storytelling.  People gathered in each other’s homes to perform tasks such as spinning wool or making clothing, and sang songs or told stories to keep everyone’s mind off the tedious tasks.

If life took you away from your community, the folk tales you had learned took on even more importance.  After working all day in a new place, what better way to relax in the evening than to listen to a story?  Of course, at some point, you would be expected to contribute.  Tales became a form of currency for the wandering poor, the itinerant student, and discharged soldiers.  If you became a servant in someone’s house, your employer might expect you to lull him or her to sleep with a tale.  And if you joined the military, you had better be ready to tell an interesting story after lights out.  Anyone who could not was forced to shout into a stove, “Oh mother!  Haven’t you brought me up to be a big brute of an ass, who hasn’t even been taught to tell a tale!”

In his blog, author Kevin J. Anderson relates how he and Brian Herbert have been forced to shorten their book tours.

“The very nature of bookselling and promotion is changing dramatically with the closing of the Borders chain, Barnes & Noble announcing the closing of another 100 stores, the rise of eBooks and online bookselling. Another factor: newspapers and local TV news have dropped most of their coverage of book events so it’s nearly impossible to get any sort of media attention for a book signing (especially for the middle book in an original trilogy). Many publishers are dropping their author tours entirely.”

So even bestselling authors have been affected by this societal trend.  Locus Magazine’s February issue is always devoted to the year in review, and this year it highlighted how the number of publishers is increasing.  Traditionally, the major publishers produced certain types, or forms, of fiction.  For example, a Science Fiction or Fantasy reader knew what type of book Baen or Tor published.  With the proliferation of publishers, and the rising ease (and acceptance) of self-publishing, authors will be empowered to write any type of story without adhering to traditional rules.  This may more it difficult for the reader to know what to expect from any particular book, and hence derive satisfaction from the reading experience.

To a certain extent, I think the popularity of ABC TV’s “Once Upon A Time” reflects this evolution in storytelling.  The series follows a soap opera format, with no episode expected to stand on its own.  Hence, a viewer cannot watch a single episode and instantly understand the characters.  Nor does it restrict itself to European fairy tale types.  This season, they’ve introduced Mulan and Doctor Frankenstein as characters.  But does overall story logic matter, provided each episode entertains us, and causes us to tune in next week? 

Folktales in Hungary were always considered passing entertainment rather than art.  With reduced barriers to entry, will overall quality deteriorate?  And with the loss of the gatekeepers, such as the traditional publishers and bookstores, will Fiction still build communities?  Will it uphold genres?  Can Fiction survive the translation to a mostly eBook format?  Or will books become a passing diversion, easily downloaded like any other type of computer file, and no more memorable than this—or any other—blog post?

Dragon Dave

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

The Bitterest Pill


Despite their friendship and mutual regard, the differences between C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien gradually drew the two apart.  Beyond Lewis’ marriage to Joy Gresham, a woman Tolkien disproved of, and beyond Lewis’ friendship with Charles Williams, a cult-like figure whose wild imaginings broke the rules of what Tolkien considered proper storytelling and religious belief, there was the matter of Lewis’ literary success.  Tolkien enjoyed acclaim in scholarly circles, and his first novel The Hobbit was successful enough to warrant a sequel.  But throughout the years of their friendship, Lewis enjoyed far more success as an author.  One need only compare the two men’s bibliographies to appreciate the yawing gap that separated them in this regard.  

While Tolkien plodded along quietly on The Lord of the Rings, Lewis kept the editors at his publishing houses ecstatic with his prodigious output.  The Narnia series proved the bitterest pill for Tolkien to swallow.  He regarded the Narnia books as ill conceived and structurally unsound.  With each volume, Lewis produced a jumble of Fantasy constructs, such as Father Christmas, talking animals, and centaurs.  Where was the cohesive system, the history and culture, the underlying rationale that would account for a collection of elements drawn from such unrelated historical and mythological sources?   If it existed, Tolkien could not perceive it.  Instead, it seemed to him as if Lewis simply threw out a new character, creature, or idea when the plot began to slow, or when he needed to steer the story in a different direction.  This might not be something as wild and improper as Williams’ stories, but it lacked the consistency and the structure that Tolkien had thought Lewis believed in.  Worse, the Narnia books were universally praised and loved.

At times, I’ve had difficulty looking at the People and Publishing section of Locus Magazine.  Each month, the magazine lists a slew of book deals made between publishers and authors.  Books are contracted.  Manuscripts are delivered.  Advances are paid.  Film, television, and other lucrative rights are sold.  Awards are bestowed.  Meanwhile, I labor away in obscurity, never quite finishing my stories, always believing that I’m pursuing the proper course.  Yet, like a mirage, completion lingers just beyond my reach.  Of course, I envy my fellow writers for their achievements.  Yet…I am who I am.  Wishing I were someone different will not help me in any way. 

So what if some authors, like C. S. Lewis, publish several bestselling books each year?  So what if others, like Charles Williams, have built an enthusiastic following?  What is that to me?  I have my own destiny to fulfill.  I must swallow the bitter pill of patience, and celebrate the triumphs of my contemporaries.  Only in that way can I retain a positive perspective, and contribute to the lives of others, regardless of whatever success eventually comes my way.

Dragon Dave

Friday, July 27, 2012

C. J. Cherryh: Exceptional & Accessible

An exception novel, by an exceptional author.

Even before I finally met her, I knew she was an exceptional author. 

In 1998, I attended Westercon, my first real Science Fiction convention.  There I purchased a subscription to “Locus,” a monthly magazine that covers the Science Fiction and Fantasy literary market.  Reviewers regularly praised novels by C. J. Cherryh.  Those same novels almost always landed on the Recommended Reading list each February, from which subscribers vote on the Locus awards.  At some point, I learned she had won several Hugo awards, which are voted upon by the members of each year’s World Science Fiction Convention.  After awhile, I began attending local conventions, where I heard her work frequently cited by panelists.  Over time, it grew clear to me what an influential author she was.

When she was selected a few years back as the Guest of Honor at Condor, my local convention, I realized I needed to buckle down and start reading her books.  Yet reading Fiction is an instinctive process that defies my best intentions.  I can be looking forward to reading a particular book, but when I pick it up, I suddenly realize that, for whatever reason, something in me is calling me to read something else.  Because of this, books that I want to read immediately sometimes linger for years before something in my brain decides, “Okay, it’s that book’s time now.”

Such was the case with C. J. Cherryh.  Her Hugo-winning novel, Downbelow Station, had sat on my shelf for years.  Finally, a few weeks before the convention, I picked it up and started reading it.  Yet, even though I knew I would see her shortly, and had looked forward to reading this book seemingly forever, I just couldn’t immerse myself in the story.  So reluctantly, I set the book aside.  At least I’d be able to listen to her insights during the panel discussions, even if I lacked a basic understanding of her work and career.

Then it happened.  I saw her standing in the con suite, enjoying a snack between panels.  She seemed approachable.  And suddenly it struck me I had something to ask with her about: her strong relationship with the DAW publishing company.  Having read “Locus” for so long, I had read a lot about its founder, Donald A Wollheim.  He had helped many great authors such as Robert Silverberg and Roger Zelazny launch their careers, had edited and run publishing houses before starting his own, and had proved instrumental in developing the SF and Fantasy paperback field.  Yet he was also something of a divisive figure in publishing.  It seemed as if I was regularly reading some criticism about his business methods, or the way he took advantage of his authors.  One case in particular bothered me: reports that Donald Wollheim had printed paperback editions of The Lord of the Rings without J. R. R. Tolkien’s permission. 

C. J. Cherryh had known Donald Wollheim personally.  Even if he had discovered her, I couldn’t believe that such a well liked and highly regarded author would have stuck by someone as unethical as some reports had painted him.  I asked her about him, treading carefully at first, knowing that she had developed strong links with the Wollheim family and Sheila Gilbert, who with Donald’s daughter Elizabeth (or Betsy) now runs DAW.  I soon found the time flowing by as she told me story after story of his kindnesses to her and other authors, and illuminated me as to what had really occurred on each of the issues I raised.  After I had spoken with her awhile, I respectfully asked her about the charges regarding Tolkien.  Her explanation of Donald’s actions seemed logical and reasonable, and overall, I gained the sense of a man who cared deeply about authors, their work, and the SF and Fantasy field.

I found her to be an utterly delightful conversationalist, completely without airs.  Some authors might have feigned outrage at my audacity to even respectfully ask such questions.  She took them at face value, recognizing that I was interested not only in her personal history, but wanted to fully understand such an important historical figure in Science Fiction publishing.  Nor did she seem upset that I asked her no questions specific to her stories.  Not once did she look at her watch, search out others to talk to, try to steer the conversation onto another topic of her choosing, or invent an excuse to back out of our conversation gracefully. 

In the end, I was the one to break off our discussion, as there was a panel coming up that I wished to attend.  I got the feeling she really enjoyed our conversation, and would have willingly spoken with me for as long as I desired.  Because of C. J. Cherryh, I also know that if I ever have the honor of being published by DAW, I would be well cared for as a writer.  That means a lot, given the constant uncertainties surrounding the publication field and authors' careers. 

After the convention, I found myself picking up Downbelow Station.  I bonded with her characters and their dilemmas.  I couldn’t turn the pages fast enough.  When the novel ended, I understood why it had won the Hugo award.  Yet more than that: I was devastated that the story was over.  So the next time I headed out to the bookstore, I sought out more novels by C. J. Cherryh, whom I had come to realize was not only friendly, gracious and completely down-to-Earth, but also an author of exceptional storytelling ability. 

Reminiscing about a literary role model,
Dragon Dave

Related Dragon Cache entries

Related Internet Links