Showing posts with label The Lord of the Rings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Lord of the Rings. Show all posts

Monday, January 5, 2015

Calling All Hobbits


Thirty-five years ago, a friend loaned me his copy of The Silmarillion. The book had recently come out, and I eagerly opened the hardcover volume, looking forward to taking a great journey alongside Bilbo Baggins, his nephew Frodo, or some other Hobbit, Dwarf, or Human hero. Imagine my surprise when I discovered this was a collection of stories, highly mythological or historical in nature. Instead of easily following the narrative, I found myself lost, bewildered, and bored. I closed the book, and ultimately returned it to my friend. It remains one of the few great Science Fiction or Fantasy books that I gave up on, and never finished.

For as long as he could remember reading, Tolkien claimed he had been writing stories about different peoples, their cultures, and inventing their myths, legends, and languages. Those stories would make up The Silmarillion, which apparently cover the First and Second Ages of Middle Earth. Last Saturday marked the One Hundred and Twenty-Third anniversary of Tolkien's birth. Had he not died, J.R.R. Tolkien would be now be older than Bilbo at the beginning of The Lord of the Rings, which occurs during the Third Age of Middle Earth. It seems a fitting time for me to pick this book up again, and give it another try. 

If, like me, you've always wanted to read to learn more about Middle Earth, why not pick up The Silmarillion and read it with me? I'd appreciate hearing your feedback as I undertake the demands of this dense tome. And if you've also had problems getting through the book, perhaps we can make better sense of it together. After all, neither Bilbo nor Frodo departed Hobbiton alone. Each had his faithful friends to travel with, and help make his journey more manageable and enjoyable. I'd be honored to have another hobbit to travel alongside on this great adventure. Or even a Dwarf, or a Human hero.

Dragon Dave

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

The Familiar Flavor of Terry Brooks




In my youth, I enjoyed Terry Brooks’ first three Shannara novels so much that I revisited them numerous times.  But I had never read the prequel to his first novel, The Sword of Shannara, which he published roughly two decades later, and it has been a long time since I’ve read any of his stories.

I found diving into First King of Shannara refreshing, and at the same time comforting, hungry as I was to recapture the magic his novels once held for me.  Brooks certainly knows how to tell an entertaining story, and his prose flowed smoothly as he introduced me to his characters and the dilemmas they faced.  He threw a lot of history at me in the opening chapters, but then he gave me a breather as Bremen returns to Paranor, the center of Druid learning.  There he tries to warn them that the evil Brona is leading an army of Gnomes, Trolls, and Skull Bearers to invade the land.  I enjoyed meeting his friends, and hoped that he could convince the council to accept his arguments.  Unfortunately, just as they once expelled him from their order, the Druids refused to see his point of view.  So they again cast him out.  But this time, some of his friends accompanied him, recognizing his wisdom, and the urgency of the situation.

Returning to Shannara as I did, without remembering much from the original trilogy, the novel struck me afresh, yet soothed me with a sense of déjà vu.  I enjoyed following the protagonists as they fought Brona’s minions, sought out the magical items necessary to combat the villain, and repeatedly faced off against the forces of evil.  I felt sad when the characters I had come to care about died, but rejoiced in the survivors’ triumphs.  With his prequel, Terry Brooks left me satisfied, and interested in rereading that first great novel, The Sword of Shannara, as well as the ones that immediately followed.

As a teen, J. R. R. Tolkien’s novels left me wanting more great stories like The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings.  In Terry Brooks, I found a writer who sated my hunger.  While my palate has evolved since my teens, it’s comforting to know that I can occasionally order a former favorite off the menu, savor its familiar flavors, and leave the table satisfied.  If, after watching Peter Jackson’s films, or reading Tolkien’s books, you find your stomach rumbling, might I suggest a house special: one of Terry Brooks’ delicious and satisfying Shannara entrees?

Dragon Dave

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Falling In Love With A Totally New Hobbit




One of the seminal events of my life was when a friend loaned me his paperback copy of The Hobbit in Junior High.  While I had read Fantasy novels before, J. R. R. Tolkien’s story was wholly different from anything I had encountered before.  One of the first things I did, after I finished the book and gave it back to him, was buy my own copy.  Then I read it again.

Perhaps because the story remains so precious to me, I felt somewhat reluctant to see "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" in the cinema.  This is nothing against Peter Jackson: I had, for the most part, enjoyed his adaptations of The Lord of the Rings.  Of all the filmmakers out there, he was the one I most trusted to bring Tolkien’s story to the big screen.  Yet I told myself not to expect too much from the adaptation, and put off seeing it. 

Sitting in the cinema, there were aspects of the movie I loved, such as the look of Bilbo’s house and Hobbiton.  I loved the way Jackson brought the dwarves to life, giving them each their own personalities.  I loved the way he way he captured the silliness of the dwarves’ song as they hurled Bilbo’s precious plates and saucers while they clean up after themselves.  I loved the visual scope of Bilbo, Gandalf, and the dwarves journey across the incredible landscape of Middle Earth (which some insist is really New Zealand). 

Yet, there were also aspects that kept me at a distance from the movie as I watched it.  By adding so much to the story, it seemed as if Jackson slowed the pace to a crawl.  Perhaps because I saw it in 2D, or because it had been filmed at 48 frames per second, I felt like I was seeing too much: every scene looked like it was taking place on a set, and refused to blend into the background.  He added extra characters and situations that I didn’t remember, that made the movie darker, and more in keeping with the tone of The Lord of the Rings.  But most of all, I kept on expecting certain scenes to play out a given way, only for the characters to surprise me, and resolve the momentary conflict in a different fashion.  I couldn’t believe my memory of those scenes was faulty: clearly Jackson was tinkering with Tolkien’s story, changing those precious moments in a way he felt superior for moviegoers.

How dare he tamper with Tolkienian perfection!

Although I wasn’t anxious to see it again, my wife asked for "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" for her birthday.  As we don’t have a 3D TV or Blu-ray player, we watched the 2D version of the film.  With this second viewing, I found that everything I loved about the movie remained the same, yet those aspects I had disliked faded away.  The pace seemed well adjusted to the story, and the additional scenes and characters, no doubt drawn from sources such as The Silmarillion, blended better into the overall story.  Likewise, the foregrounds and backgrounds blended together on my smaller screen, so I no longer felt as if I were watching actors on a physical set.  Most important, this time I found myself more accepting of the different way certain key scenes played out (at least from the way I remember them). 

I don’t know why, but sometimes aspects of a movie I disliked at first fade away with a repeated viewing.  If you love the novel, but experienced a similar reaction to "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" in the cinema, I suggest that you try a second viewing.  Perhaps, like me, you’ll find you enjoy it more the second time around.  As for me, watching the movie again made me want to read The Hobbit again.  I don’t think I will, because I don’t want to be comparing the novel with the second and third films while in the cinema, but now I feel drawn to make that second attempt at (and actually read all the way through) The Silmarillion.  I also want to read Terry Brooks’ High Fantasy novels again, like The Sword of Shannara.  Ooh, and I’d also like to reread Jim C. Hines' humorous Goblin trilogy, and…

Dragon Dave

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

The Bitterest Pill


Despite their friendship and mutual regard, the differences between C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien gradually drew the two apart.  Beyond Lewis’ marriage to Joy Gresham, a woman Tolkien disproved of, and beyond Lewis’ friendship with Charles Williams, a cult-like figure whose wild imaginings broke the rules of what Tolkien considered proper storytelling and religious belief, there was the matter of Lewis’ literary success.  Tolkien enjoyed acclaim in scholarly circles, and his first novel The Hobbit was successful enough to warrant a sequel.  But throughout the years of their friendship, Lewis enjoyed far more success as an author.  One need only compare the two men’s bibliographies to appreciate the yawing gap that separated them in this regard.  

While Tolkien plodded along quietly on The Lord of the Rings, Lewis kept the editors at his publishing houses ecstatic with his prodigious output.  The Narnia series proved the bitterest pill for Tolkien to swallow.  He regarded the Narnia books as ill conceived and structurally unsound.  With each volume, Lewis produced a jumble of Fantasy constructs, such as Father Christmas, talking animals, and centaurs.  Where was the cohesive system, the history and culture, the underlying rationale that would account for a collection of elements drawn from such unrelated historical and mythological sources?   If it existed, Tolkien could not perceive it.  Instead, it seemed to him as if Lewis simply threw out a new character, creature, or idea when the plot began to slow, or when he needed to steer the story in a different direction.  This might not be something as wild and improper as Williams’ stories, but it lacked the consistency and the structure that Tolkien had thought Lewis believed in.  Worse, the Narnia books were universally praised and loved.

At times, I’ve had difficulty looking at the People and Publishing section of Locus Magazine.  Each month, the magazine lists a slew of book deals made between publishers and authors.  Books are contracted.  Manuscripts are delivered.  Advances are paid.  Film, television, and other lucrative rights are sold.  Awards are bestowed.  Meanwhile, I labor away in obscurity, never quite finishing my stories, always believing that I’m pursuing the proper course.  Yet, like a mirage, completion lingers just beyond my reach.  Of course, I envy my fellow writers for their achievements.  Yet…I am who I am.  Wishing I were someone different will not help me in any way. 

So what if some authors, like C. S. Lewis, publish several bestselling books each year?  So what if others, like Charles Williams, have built an enthusiastic following?  What is that to me?  I have my own destiny to fulfill.  I must swallow the bitter pill of patience, and celebrate the triumphs of my contemporaries.  Only in that way can I retain a positive perspective, and contribute to the lives of others, regardless of whatever success eventually comes my way.

Dragon Dave

Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Yearning To Stretch


J. R. R. Tolkien wrote The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, two of the most important stories of the twentieth century.  But before he could write those novels, and particularly the latter one, he had to create Middle Earth, the Fantasy world in which they took place.  For Tolkien, everything in those novels had to fit together into a logical, coherent system.  Thus, after he finished The Hobbit, he spent over a decade developing and enlarging Middle Earth, while he worked on The Lord of the Rings.  It wasn’t enough for a given character to hold a sword, for example.  For his novel to be complete, Tolkien felt he must create the races and cultures that mined the ore, refined the metal, and fashioned the sword.  Equal consideration would be devoted to the sword, which would be covered in runes and carvings, and sheathed in a history of previous owners and battles waged.  Of course, he also needed to know the history, culture, agriculture, beliefs, and all sorts of other things about the peoples involved in every stage of the creation and life of the sword.  And we haven’t even talked about the individual wielding the sword yet: his history, family, and aspirations.

Tolkien felt that all of these types of facts, very little of which would actually appear in the finished narrative, were necessary infrastructure for his Fantasy novel.  A writer more prolific, such as his friend C. S. Lewis, would no doubt have disagreed.  Lewis wrote many fiction and nonfiction books that were popular in his day.  Like Tolkien’s work, they have also transcended their time.  Yet Lewis was not a Worldbuilder like Tolkien.  It was enough for him to select a given idea he wished to pursue, brainstorm a few characters, story elements or essay points, and then leap into his writing.  Lewis also diverged from Tolkien in other ways.  He chose the Church of England over the Catholic Church, he married a divorced woman, and he promoted Charles Williams, a Christian author who combined Christian viewpoints and teachings with secular issues and beliefs, in the process transforming what conservatives like Tolkien might see as unquestionable and settled religious teachings into spurious, if not heretical theological concepts.  

Both men were Oxford educators, passionate about their faith, and talented writers.  Yet Tolkien simply wasn’t as inclusive as Lewis.  Tolkien must have tried to stretch himself: his friendship with Lewis, despite the other's differing beliefs and actions, seems like proof of that.  Still, he also had to retreat to his comfort zone, where he knew who he was and what he believed, in order to finish building Middle Earth, and then complete The Lord of the Rings. 

As much as a voice inside tells me that much of my Worldbuilding is unnecessary, like Tolkien I feel I must build a foundation firm enough to support the Fantasy elements of my eventual novel.  So I labor each day to complete what work I can, concentrating on my own strengths, and operating from the serenity and security of my comfort zone.  Yet, as Tolkien did, I also try to learn from those around me, those whose beliefs and actions sometimes clash with mine.  Only God (whatever you call Him, and however you define Him) is omnipotent.  He alone encompasses everything.  I, like J. R. R. Tolkien, am a limited mortal.  I may be more rock than rubber band, more brittle than elastic, but still, as a writer, and as a man, I yearn to stretch.

Dragon Dave

Sunday, November 11, 2012

The Return of The Hobbit: Part 1


Three decades ago, a friend pressed a paperback into my hands.  The novel was The Hobbit by J. R. R. Tolkien, and it told the story of Bilbo Baggins, a hobbit whose life is changed forever when he meets a human wizard named Gandalf.  Reading the story opened my eyes to everything that a good fantasy novel could be.

I’ve never read just one kind of literature, although Science Fiction has always been a strong favorite.  I know I must have read Fantasy novels before this, but The Hobbit transcended everything else I had read that even approached that type of literature.  I’ve read hundreds, if not thousands of Fantasy novels since then, and I’ve enjoyed many of them.  But I’m not sure I’ve ever read another Fantasy novel that had quite as great an impact upon me. 

Not everyone feels that way about The Hobbit.  In fact, most people don’t.  Even J. R. R. Tolkien later grew dissatisfied with The Hobbit.  He pursued a darker vision with his next novel, and in the process created an infinitely more complex world for The Lord of the Rings (which was then split into three books and labeled a trilogy by publishers).  I sought out The Lord of the Rings shortly after finishing The Hobbit.  But I found myself unable to embrace the latter work with the same enthusiasm as I had the original. 

The Hobbit reads a whimsical, engaging serial.  It reminds me of a story told over a campfire, invented on the spur of the moment, with only the storyteller’s wits and the expectation in his audience’s eyes to propel him toward its completion.  The Lord of the Rings, on the other hand, seems like a conglomeration of interrelated stories.  As Tolkien lavished so much love and care upon his characters and Middle Earth, some of the best stories didn't actually make it into the novel. (Thankfully, Tolkien included these in the appendices he included at the end of the third installment, The Return of the King).  My recollection, from reading Humphrey Carpenter’s biographical work The Inklings, is that The Lord of the Rings grew beyond Tolkien’s ability to complete, and it was only through the help of his son Christopher that he eventually assembled it into its final form.  Director Peter Jackson is largely recognized as having assembled The Lord of the Rings into a more coherent, and more entertaining version of the novel (or, if you prefer, the trilogy). 

I can’t offer you my opinion on the above assertion, as I haven’t read The Lord of the Rings in many years, certainly not since I’ve seen the movies.  But I read The Hobbit a couple years ago, when my wife gave me a new hardcover edition, complete with some beautiful illustrations.  While that reading couldn’t compare with my first eye-opening experience, it was wonderful to accompany Bilbo Baggins again on a journey that changed him forever.  For I too was transformed by the imaginative and lighthearted story.  In an instant, J. R. R. Tolkien made me want to read other stories as great as The Hobbit.  Eventually, he inspired me to write my own.

Dragon Dave